2 ms·
Neither of them use randomized control group. The second one just compare the countries "community-directed treatment with ivermectin" with the other countries
by gus_massa 5y ago
Neither of them use randomized control group.
The second one just compare the countries "community-directed treatment with ivermectin" with the other countries. As they note, the countries that don't use ivermectin systematically have a average life expectancy of 6 years greater than the others. So they are quite different. A 6 years of difference in life expectancy may mean that they have better hospitals (that probably should reduce the covid-19 mortality) but also that they have more old people that has worse prognosis (that probably should increase the covid-19 mortality). So ... it's difficult to compare the two kind of countries and get a conclusion, that's why it's important to have randomized control group.
The first one is very similar, but they use the African Programme for Onchocerciasis Control (APOC), from 1995 until 2015, and the countries that were/are not in that programme. (What happened between 2015 and 2020?) Anyway, they control for different factors, including the Human Development Index (HDI), that should fix the problem with the available hospitals and the age, or not, it's difficult to be sure. At least they are trying, but without a randomized control group is difficult to be sure.