5 ms·
Do you have a reputable source for that? I've never heard that before, it seems to defy intuition in a couple of ways, and it defies my own electricity bill. F
by crazygringo 5y ago
Do you have a reputable source for that? I've never heard that before, it seems to defy intuition in a couple of ways, and it defies my own electricity bill.
First, water vapor in air is usually less than 2% of air by mass, and contrary to what you say there's absolutely no phase change involved -- water vapor isn't steam, it's far far below boiling. And AC usually doesn't condense more than about 25% of humidity, so it's really a tiny, tiny amount of water being cooled relative to air being cooled. So I'm missing what could possible be so energy-intensive about cooling water vapor, or why condensation would be relevant to energy usage at all? (Cool condensation still helps "chill" the room.)
And second, even if that were the case, wouldn't it be the identical energy loss when heating? A heat pump in the winter is literally just air-conditioning the outside, and produces similar condensation in the unit outdoors. In fact, my heat pump runs in reverse for ~15 min once or twice a day on really cold days (suddenly it blows cold air inside and warm air outside) in order to melt the accumulated ice from condensation, to continue operating safely.
So I don't see at all how how cooling somehow uses 3.5x more energy than heating. My personal electric bill with my heat pump is also about 2x as expensive in the coldest winter months (heating from 25°F to 70°F = +45°F) as in the warmest summer months (cooling from 90°F to 70°F = -20°F). If your math were correct, it would be roughly the opposite.
As far as I can tell, the cost of running a heat pump is basically the same no matter which direction you're running it.
- sokoloff 5y agoIn HVAC design, the two concepts are called sensible heat (temperature change) and latent heat (dehumidification). If you just cool the air without removing water vapor, you will drive up the relative humidity and often decrease occupant comfort.
- crazygringo 5y agoThat doesn't address anything I said about costs. And you often can't cool air without removing water vapor, the water condenses whether you want it to or not.
- sokoloff 5y agoYou appear to have previously to be laboring under the misconception that latent heat (the heat required to condense water in gaseous form into water in liquid form) didn’t exist or that humidity isn’t gaseous water. My comment was directly responsive to whichever of those misconceptions was underlying your comment above. That’s why I gave you the term, in an effort to show you politely that you were wrong enough that the HVAC industry has an entire term specific to this concept and that suggests that it’s more than a rounding error. It appears that you at least now agree that water in gas form is condensing into liquid form (which requires the removal of the heat of vaporization [what science calls it] or the latent heat [what HVAC calls it]).
- crazygringo 5y agoAh ha, thank you! I was indeed under the misperception that latent heat was associated only with evaporation/condensation at high-energy boiling points, not at e.g. room temperature for water. Turns out it's fiendishly difficult to find anything on Google or educational materials about phase changes or latent heat that aren't at a boiling (or freezing) point -- no wonder I was never taught it. (Finally found [1].) But in any case, I finally found them and ran the numbers. The latent heat of water is ~4x that of air, but even on a really hot humid summer day water is only 3% of air by mass, which means in a worst-case common scenario, 11% of energy is going to condensing the water, while 89% is simply cooling the air and (non-condensing) humidity. So if we round, we can say that a heat pump cooling humid summer air rather than drier winter air uses up to around 10% more energy (since winter air has a bit of humidity too), which means heating/cooling are still roughly the same for most purposes. Whereas the commenter I was originally replying to seemed to be suggesting cooling takes 3.5x as much energy, which doesn't seem to match summer/winter energy bills at all. Does that cover it, or is there something else my math is missing? Thanks again. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latent_heat#Specific_latent_heat_for_condensation_of_water_in_clouds https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latent_heat#Specific_latent_he...
- sokoloff 5y agoI think it’s more than that. (Sorry for the use of “stupid units” here. It’s a lot easier to find the non-SI units for the HVAC applications of these and being an American, it’s easier for me to think in BTUs than calories, kWh, or Joules for HVAC.) It takes (negative) 970 BTU to condense one pound of water from gas to liquid. (That’s the latent heat of vaporization.) It takes -0.24 BTU to cool one pound of mixed air by one degree Fahrenheit. At 90°F, air can hold almost 5% of water vapor in suspension. If the task is to condense out about half the water (from 90% to 45% RH) and cool it from 90°F to 70°F, I think it’s: For every 40 pounds of 90°F/90% RH air that you want to make into comfortable inside air: You condense out 1 pound of water at a cost of sinking 970BTU. It’s slightly less than 1 pound, so generously call it 900BTU of latent heat removal. You then cool 39 pounds of mixed air by delta-T of 20°F: 39 * 20 * .24: 195BTU of cooling required for sensible heat removal. That makes it look to me like over 80% of the heat removal is latent and under 20% is sensible. (Phase change is expensive, but you’re glad for that when you’re sweating in air that’s not 100% RH.) This is tapped out on a phone while traveling, so I’m not staking my life on it, but I think it’s right.
- sokoloff 5y ago> contrary to what you say there's absolutely no phase change involved -- water vapor isn't steam There is absolutely phase change (and associated heat of vaporization energy) involved in humidity/water vapor (which is a gas) condensing into liquid water.
- pdonis 5y ago> Do you have a reputable source for that? My experience as an HVAC engineer, which was some time ago, hence why I said "off the top of my head". However, it's easy to check by running some numbers. The cases to be compared are: A/C -- 38 C x 80% relative humidity (typical for a hot, humid climate) to 23 C x 50% RH (a dewpoint of about 12 C, which is typical as an output for air conditioners). Heating -- -10 C to 22 C, no change in dewpoint. We'll need some physical properties of air and water; approximate values will be good enough (i.e., we'll ignore that these values change with temperature and treat them as constant): Air -- density about 1 kg/m^3, specific heat about 1000 J/kg per degree C Water -- density about 1000 kg/m^3, specific heat about 4000 J/kg per degree C, latent heat of vaporization about 2.3 x 10^6 J/kg (note how huge that value is--that's key to the comparison we'll be making) We'll also need to make some assumptions about the volume of air being cooled or heated; I'm going to use a round figure of 300 cubic meters, which I think is fairly average for a home (about 200 square meters of floor area times 1.5 meters of height). Finally, we'll need the moisture content of air at the two A/C points we gave. We can get that by taking saturation values from the Engineering Toolbox [1] and multiplying by the relative humidity (since that is just the percentage of the saturation value that is actually present in the air). We'll have to interpolate because the table only has values for 20, 30, and 40 C. The values I get are: 38 C -- 0.047 kg/m^3 x .8 = 0.038 kg/m^3 23 C -- 0.021 kg/m^3 x .5 = 0.011 kg/m^3 So the difference in moisture content is 0.027 kg/m^3; that's what has to be condensed out of the air. Now we can calculate the heat transfer required: A/C cooling air -- 15 C x 1000 J / kg-C x 1 kg/m^3 x 300 m^3 = 4.5 x 10^6 J A/C condensing water vapor -- 2.3 x 10^6 J/kg x 0.027 kg/m^3 x 300 m^3 = 18.6 x 10^6 J So my memory was somewhat off: the condensing heat transfer is only about 4 times the cooling heat transfer, not 6. Still big, though. Heating air -- 32 C x 1000 J / kg-C x 1 kg/m^3 x 300 m^3 = 9.6 x 10^6 J So heating for these temperatures is a little more than twice the air cooling heat transfer, but only about half of the condensing heat transfer, so about 2/5 of the total A/C heat transfer. Note that, as the condensing calculation above makes clear, the relative humidity at the higher temperature is a huge factor. In desert conditions (for example, 38 C x 25% RH, typical for, say, Phoenix, Arizona as opposed to Houston, Texas), the moisture content of the air is only 0.012 kg/m^3, i.e., only a little higher than at the 23 C x 50% RH target point, so the condensation heat transfer goes way down. So if you're used to hot, dry conditions as opposed to hot, wet conditions, then your intuition that the condensation heat transfer isn't that large is correct. But many locations where A/C is used are are hot and wet. [1] https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/maximum-moisture-content-air-d_1403.html https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/maximum-moisture-content-... > contrary to what you say there's absolutely no phase change involved There most certainly is: water vapor is vapor, and the condensate that comes out of your air conditioner is liquid. Go look at your home air conditioner: there will be a line coming off of it that drains condensate (liquid water) somewhere, usually into your home's sump. Or look under your car after you've been running the A/C for a while: you will see a puddle of water, which is liquid condensed from water vapor in the air.
- pdonis 5y ago> A heat pump in the winter is literally just air-conditioning the outside, and produces similar condensation in the unit outdoors. It produces condensation, yes, but the total heat transfer spent on that condensation is still pretty small, because now the condensation isn't removing moisture from the inside air, it's removing moisture from the outside air that is blowing past the heat pump's outside heat exchanger. So the amount of water vapor being condensed is only based on the difference between the ambient outdoor air temperature and the temperature of the outdoor air just after it's blown past the outdoor heat exchanger, which might only be 5 degrees C or so--say -10 C (ambient) to -15 C. From the Engineering Toolbox [1], that's 0.00231 - 0.00158 = 0.00073 kg/m^3 of air. With a latent heat of 2.6 x 10^6 J/kg (since we now have to count the latent heat of both condensation of vapor to liquid and freezing of liquid to ice), that's about 1900 J per cubic meter of air. So it would take about 5000 cubic meters of air being blown past the outside heat exchanger for the heat transfer due to ice formation to equal the heat transfer to heat up the inside of the house from -10 C to 22 C (which I calculated in my previous post a few minutes ago). I don't know the exact outside airflow of a heat pump, but that seems like a lot more outside air than would be needed for the necessary run time of the heat pump for that amount of heating. [1] https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/maximum-moisture-content-air-d_1403.html https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/maximum-moisture-content-... > As far as I can tell, the cost of running a heat pump is basically the same no matter which direction you're running it. Not in terms of heat transfer, no; comparing the calculations in my previous post with the above, it should be evident that it makes a big difference which heat exchanger is doing the condensation of water vapor (inside or outside).
- pdonis 5y ago> My personal electric bill with my heat pump is also about 2x as expensive in the coldest winter months (heating from 25°F to 70°F = +45°F) as in the warmest summer months (cooling from 90°F to 70°F = -20°F). What is the typical humidity at 90 F where you live? As my previous calculations showed, that makes a huge difference to the heat transfer required. From the costs you give, I suspect your area is not very humid (say 50% RH at 90 F, vs. 80% or 90%, which is more typical in a hot, humid climate). For a home, there are also other significant variables, such as how much sunlight vs. shade your home gets, how well insulated it is, how often you open the doors and windows, etc. Those variables can affect heating and cooling differently, which makes any comparison harder.