3 ms·
Can you both comment and downvote? I have a vague recollection from back in the old days when you could see vote totals that if I downvoted someone and then rep
by tzs 5y ago
Can you both comment and downvote? I have a vague recollection from back in the old days when you could see vote totals that if I downvoted someone and then replied to them that removed the downvote. I could be thinking of some other site, though.
Anyway, there are a couple of problems that come to mind with the proposal.
1. If someone says something that draws a lot of downvotes there is going to be a lot of redundancy in the required comments. Do we really need or want the worst comments to have dozens of replies all giving the same reason for downvoting?
2. It will attract trolls who enjoy posting downvote worthy things for the enjoyment of knowing that people have to waste time commenting in order to downvote them.
You could maybe fix these problems by having an option to instead of writing a new comment explaining your downvote cite an existing comment.