3 ms·
First, no, you can't force "respectful". Second, here's someone who leaves a lazy, drive-by comment. It's two words long. It took them five seconds. It has
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
First, no, you can't force "respectful".
Second, here's someone who leaves a lazy, drive-by comment. It's two words long. It took them five seconds. It has no actual thought, and therefore it's not the kind of comment we want on HN. How long should someone have to spend to be able to downvote it? If it's longer than 5 seconds, that's a problem. That puts the lazy, thoughtless commenter in the advantageous position. So what will happen instead is that users will flag the comment instead of downvoting it, because that's faster (under your proposal).
Even if it's a more worthwhile comment, it can be factually wrong. You may want to downvote it for that reason, but you may not have time (or mental energy) to explain why it's wrong for every such comment that you see. (The explanation is better than a bare downvote, of course, unless someone has already given the explanation.) But a downvote with "factually wrong" (and no explanation/details/evidence) isn't really going to raise the level of discourse much. I mean, it tells the original poster more than a bare downvote does, but not much more.
- tuxie_ 5y ago> First, no, you can't force "respectful". Yes, you are right. > it's not the kind of comment we want on HN I agree, but if the goal is for the OP to understand this and change, I feel like the downvote acts more like a way for the downvoter to feel better than to teach the OP what was wrong with the comment. > isn't really going to raise the level of discourse much (...) it tells the original poster more than a bare downvote does, but not much more I see what you mean, and I agree, but at the same time I think that the difference between 'nothing' and giving some feedback is in my opinion what makes the difference between making downvoting about retaliation vs. teaching and correcting behavior.
- joshmanders 5y ago> Second, here's someone who leaves a lazy, drive-by comment. It's two words long. It took them five seconds. It has no actual thought, and therefore it's not the kind of comment we want on HN. Every time the subject of downvotes come up on HN, this is always the stance most people take, but in reality HN has grown to the point that people are downvoting with a hive-mind like reaction. Look at the sibling comment to mine by tuxie_. I see no reason why their post should be downvoted, yet it is. I personally think downvoting on HN has become large scale deterrence of any discourse that goes against the hive-mind or is provocative, because people drive by downvote, then someone sees that comment is downvoted and piles on because "Well if the community thinks they're wrong, then I do to."
- nathanaldensr 5y agoWhen in reality, "the community" is often juuuust enough accounts to trigger gray text--a fraction of a fraction of a percent of total accounts.