3 ms·
> Yeah, the question "do they kill innovation?" is too simplistic... They exist for a valid reason But isn't that entire reason explicitly to "promote the Prog
by ModernMech 5y ago
> Yeah, the question "do they kill innovation?" is too simplistic... They exist for a valid reason
But isn't that entire reason explicitly to "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts" aka innovation? Shouldn't we ask whether or not patents are doing the thing we want them to do?
- bluGill 5y agoHaving a patent ensures that I have all the data I need to later improve or implement it. I've read books where the steam engine were encased in explosives so that it couldn't be reversed engineered thus ensuring the inventor had a monopoly on them (the book had a lot of other things to ensure the monopoly as well). A lawyer told me years ago never read patents: if you infringe and claim ignorance that is better than infringing and knowing. If we want to make patents useful, then we need to change this to ??? which ensures engineers keep up on the relevant patents in their field. I have ideas on what to change, but every one has serious flaws so I'm not going to state any - maybe you can do better.
- the_only_law 5y ago> I've read books where the steam engine were encased in explosives so that it couldn't be reversed engineered Stop! You’ll give the HW companies ideas.
- bluGill 5y agoIf they try they will run into attempted murder issues.
- a1369209993 5y ago> I've read books where the steam engine were encased in explosives so that it couldn't be reversed engineered thus ensuring the inventor had a monopoly on them That's not a argument for patents, that's a argument for felony prosecution of interference against reverse engineering.
- MattPalmer1086 5y agoI think it is an argument for patents. The point is that before we had legal protection of ideas, knowledge was hoarded, because it has value. Trade secrets, guilds, possibly explosions! Secrecy basically. Patents change that equation. So while their existence slows down innovation while they are in operation, after they expire society as a whole has gained that knowledge. I'm not arguing that the patent system isn't horribly broken in all sorts of ways. Just that they are fulfilling a purpose in not forcing inventors to go to huge lengths to keep information secret.