5 ms·
Too easy from the technical side, too difficult/expensive from the legal side. Solo inventors and startups working on genuinely new and interesting technology d
by paxys 5y ago
Too easy from the technical side, too difficult/expensive from the legal side. Solo inventors and startups working on genuinely new and interesting technology do not have the funding to hire fancy law firms, while companies like Microsoft and IBM file a dozen patents a day (not an exaggeration). It's the exact opposite of how a patent process should work.
- deelowe 5y agoAnd a perfect example of how regulatory capture works. I don't have a solution, but I am convinced that over time this is the end result of ANY regulation. It doesn't matter what the original intent is/was.
- dantheman 5y agoThe answer is to not grant patents.
- wpietri 5y agoI look it as an evolutionary system, an arms race. Capture will happen if the regulators don't keep up. But it's possible to keep up. US financial markets have a lot of internal regulation for traders, so they're wrangling some of the most aggressive do-anything-for-a-buck people on the planet. Nonetheless, the traders are generally kept in check. I used to do tech for derivatives traders and we knew to never, ever fuck around with a market. That didn't always stop our traders, of course. We had some based in Frankfurt who hated living there. They decided they wanted to live in London, and so quietly shifted their trading terminals to our London office. This was strictly forbidden; at least at the time, the mid-90s, trading on the Deutche Terminborse was to take place on German soil and nowhere else. Eventually the regulators got suspicious and so they were standing outside ringing the bell while watching our trading activity. So one of my technical colleagues had to rent a van, load everything up, drive it 10 hours back to Frankfurt, and have it all working by the next morning. Which we did, and so avoided formal sanction, but it was close. That probably kept those traders from doing something foolish for at least another year.
- pksebben 5y agoSo, the traders did something explicitly forbidden and didn't get penalized for it; that doesn't sound like being "kept in check" to me. Never mind those manipulations that make it through the regulatory filter, a la mortgage securitization circa 2008.
- wpietri 5y agoIt was them getting kept in check, because they quickly corrected the behavior. And as far as I know, never repeated it. Explicit punishment is not the only way policing happens. Indeed, I think the most important parts happen well before that.
- laurent92 5y ago> standing outside ringing the bell while watching our trading activity Do you mean ringing manually the bell of the end-of-the-day of the stock exchange? When they rang it the first time, didn’t they catch them not going out of the building?
- wpietri 5y agoI mean they rang the doorbell. They could see that the traders were active, meaning that they were supposedly in the office. But the door was locked and nobody answered it.
- specialist 5y agoYa, like a bureaucratic DDoS attack. > regulatory capture ... is the end result of ANY regulation. All evidence to date supports this conclusion. Can we do better? Regulations are two-party, can be distilled down to us vs them. How do we make them three party? Transmute them into trilemmas? (Tripods are more stable that bipods.) Maybe grant a seat to the parties on the receiving end, the natural antagonists to the parties being regulated. And empower them appropriately.
- CalChris 5y agoThat isn’t what regulatory capture means. Regulatory capture has to do with industry vs public rather than big co vs little co. Regulatory capture is an economic theory that regulatory agencies may come to be dominated by the interests they regulate and not by the public interest. The result is that the agency instead acts in ways that benefit the interests it is supposed to be regulating. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/regulatory-capture.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/regulatory-capture.asp
- jlawson 5y agoIn this case, the small-co or independent inventor acts as a member of the public. It's really about established players being able to invest in controlling the regulators that are specific to them, while new players considering entering obviously don't have this advantage. Structurally it's similar to NIMBYism.
- deelowe 5y agoAs another commenter suggested, let's look at the data from the USPTO and see what the submission/approval ratio looks like for large cap, small cap, and independents before jumping to conclusions...
- wpietri 5y agoYup. A friend worked for a now-extinct tech company that strongly encouraged employees to patent as much as possible. On his desk, he had one of those drinking bird toys. [1] When the head got sufficiently wet, water would drip onto his desk. He made a little celluloid collar for the bird so that excess water would get dumped back into the cup the bird was drinking from. On a lark, he wrote it up as patentable innovation. His boss thought it was funny and approved it. So did the lawyers. He ended up with one of the little plaques they gave employees for patents. And maybe a cash bonus? It was long enough ago that I forget. But apparently that's what IBM does: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17835839 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17835839 [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drinking_bird https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drinking_bird
- CalChris 5y agoI think that's because IBM has a massive portfolio and just treats it statistically in IP cross-licensing negotiations. I had a boss at a company who said they added up theirs and IBM added up theirs, then his company wrote a check to IBM every year.
- gyc 5y agoIBM also plays tricks to artificially boosts the number of patents it gets. For example, for a computer-implemented invention, a patent application will generally have a set of claims for the method that a computer performs to implement the invention and a set of claims for the computing device itself configured to perform the invention. What IBM likes to do is to split those two sets of claim into separate patent applications, so one application just claims the method and another application claims the computing device. So when most other companies would only get a single patent for a computer-implemented invention, IBM would get two patents. So this helps IBM maximize licensing revenue in the example where they're just adding up the number of patents.
- svilen_dobrev 5y agoEvery big corp makes such list, and measures against others, no matter what patents there are. Nearly 20 years ago, in initial bootcamp in big-corp, there was half a day course by a patent guy, and one of the warnings he gave was "be careful where you search for your new idea" - the most wellknown patent search web site then, was owned by.. IBM.
- jackcosgrove 5y agoPatents aren't all that expensive. Defending your rights in court, however...
- CalChris 5y agoConsequently writing a PTAB review resistant patent is expensive because you really can't defend a poor drafted vanity patent after the fact.
- DethNinja 5y agoThat is just for the USA, patents are extremely expensive in EU, they got a great feudal system going on there where you cannot get a patent without spending at least 40k EUR, whereas in USA a single inventor can get it as low as 500 USD.
- WkndTriathlete 5y agoSure, the USPTO might charge $500, but the patent lawyers that will file the application for you will charge $40k - $200k.
- DethNinja 5y agoYou can actually do it yourself, there are lots of book out there how to navigate the patenting system. You don’t need to hire a lawyer if you spend some personal time but on the EU you don’t have that option at all.