3 ms·
You talk very eloquently to how much more knowledge the natural philosophers have dug up and how much more a person might be able to know. But I was born into
by rektide 5y ago
You talk very eloquently to how much more knowledge the natural philosophers have dug up and how much more a person might be able to know.
But I was born into that world. The world that has happened during my lived life has been one where a greater and greater amount of the total knowledge has been withheld, retained, kept proprietary.
And worse, a large amount of this knowledge is knowledge that is impossible for anyone else to ever figure out. Almost all manufacturers keep their processes & ingredients secret. Want to know what this Tyvek thing is that you wrap your house with? We'll give you some marketing blurb, but mostly you have to trust us. With cloud computing, with DRM, there is no observable world: where-as with Tyvek we could buy some & put it under microscopes, tear it apart, run mass-spectrometers on it, try to reproduce it, we couldn't even take our chips out, give them an acid bath, & see what they do any more, because vast amount of the functionality is behind a firewall. That knowledge is physically retained, withheld, guarded inside a data center.
And that knowledge is vast, is the very core of the business of many of the biggest companies of the world. Powering products that we interact with for hours a day.
This domain of unnatural knowledge defines more and more of the world about us. It shapes society more actively in our day to day than our relationship with the natural world, our knowledge of the sciences. In spite of being the most active force shaping the world about us, humans, it has felt to me, have less and less ability to peer into, to see, to understand the world about them. While our total knowledge grows & we have a bigger pool of knowable things- truly a wonder- as you argue, I argue that the past handful of decades have seen far more knowledge created which is un-discoverable, un-findable than at any other point. And it is knowledge of the basic world about us, of how the basic elements of our world work. This to me is an anathema.
- toomanybeersies 5y agoI generally agree with you, that proprietary knowledge isn't a good thing, but I don't don't see how things AWS Graviton are different to Tyvek or Nomex. Given the opportunity, DuPont and Amazon would hide their proprietary knowledge just the same. Maybe one chemicals are easier to reverse engineer than cloud platforms, but the intention is the same.