3 ms·
> If you can reliably A/B test properly encoded 160kbit mp3s you have exceptional hearing and you should lend your services to the lame tuning team ASAP. there
by tripzilch 15y ago
> If you can reliably A/B test properly encoded 160kbit mp3s you have exceptional hearing and you should lend your services to the lame tuning team ASAP.
there's a difference between being able to reliably distinguish them for any kind of track, and occasionally noticing compression artifacts in certain parts of certain tracks.
the first ability would indicate exceptional hearing and material for the Lame tuning team,
while the latter probably means you're useless to that tuning team, but you will still get less enjoyment from lower bitrate streams, some of the time.
I'll have to check those hydrogenaudio forums to see what "properly encoded" exactly means, btw. Because if, as you said above, encoders are just too good above 96kbps [for people to tell the difference], those must be some pretty sweet magic presets, cause I haven't been able to get that quality at such bitrates when encoding mp3s or ogg myself. It's not that I don't believe it btw, from what I've seen the hydrogenaudio people know what they're talking about. It's surprising though, that apparently some commandline switches can make such a world of difference.
However, what is relevant to this discussion, is not how a 160kbps mp3 sounds when "properly encoded", but how a 160kbps ogg sounds when encoded the way Spotify does it [which may or may not be optimal].
And to determine whether people are making a big deal out of something they ultimately can or cannot hear, they don't need to be able to reliably A/B test everything, it's enough if they are able to notice the lower bitrate some of the time for some tracks, even a littlebit is already enough to get that itchy feeling you are not quite getting what you paid for, and that alone can put a big damper on your enjoyment of the entire stream (even the parts that sound just fine!).
- cageface 15y agoProperly encoding an mp3 is just a matter of using a recent version of lame and using one of the -Vn presets. It's dead easy but a lot of people don't seem to know this somehow. Ogg is a little trickier since some of the best tuning tweaks haven't been folded into the mainline code base yet. There will probably always be "killer samples" that sound bad at any lossy bitrate. If you're really worried about this you're better off just going lossless instead of wasting tons of bits on across-the-board 320 kbit encoding.