3 ms·
I had class where the final exam was indeed a socratic style oral. It was for an ancient philosophy class (300 or 400 level - this was well beyond the 101 leve
by shagie 5y ago
I had class where the final exam was indeed a socratic style oral. It was for an ancient philosophy class (300 or 400 level - this was well beyond the 101 level) where we had studied Socrates (the dialog was on platonic forms). The exam was a 2:1 and lasted an hour if I recall correctly.
For a class of 30, this took the professor 15 hours (three hours a day over the course of a week) to have all of the students go through the exam process during exam week.
Trying to scale this up for something that can handle ~100 students becomes difficult.
Another part with this is the objective vs subjective evaluation of the student.
With the "I got a poor grade because the professor didn't like me" type issues that come up, being able to objectively point to "this is the score on the homework" and "this is the score on the final" allows that subjective grading to be removed and protects the professors from students who feel that the grade they received was influenced by external factors.
While systematizing the verification of material learned may be the wrong approach, it is where we are for a number of factors that the university doesn't have too many options (allegations of professor bias, even if unfounded, still take up a lot of time; class sizes for some classes go beyond what can be reasonably verified on a 1:1 basis)
- crazygringo 5y agoThis is exactly it. It's not scalable, and it's way too open to professor bias. Except for in some niche seminar classes, it's a non-starter.