4 ms·
An adjacent issue, not from a privacy standpoint, but from an "inappropriate use of tech" standpoint, is anti-plagiarism software. A relative of mine recently
by tyingq 5y ago
An adjacent issue, not from a privacy standpoint, but from an "inappropriate use of tech" standpoint, is anti-plagiarism software.
A relative of mine recently took an English course, and constantly had to lobby for re-evaluation of low grades caused by false positives with Turnitin[1].
The issues were varied, but the most frustrating one was that passages in her paper that were quoted and footnoted were marked as "sourced from the internet". Turns out that would happen with any passage quoted from a book that someone put on the internet, somewhere.
Of course, instructors are supposed to manually review for this sort of thing, but it's such a basic miss. One that's going to get worse over time. People put existing source material on the internet, and it gets indexed.
Also, see this example from Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/WTF/comments/h731k/thank_god_for_turnitincom_now_i_understand_what/ https://www.reddit.com/r/WTF/comments/h731k/thank_god_for_tu... Argh.
[1] https://www.turnitin.com/ https://www.turnitin.com/
- 542458 5y agoIn turnitin’s defence, in my recollection their training material explicitly and repeatedly tells you not to do this - that a positive turnitin result is not the same as plagiarism, and that all positives should be manually reviewed. The student-facing side of it can be bad, as it errs on the side of extreme caution. When I (as a TA) had to mark dozens and dozens of papers pre-screening for obviously copied paragraphs was a very nice time saver. Otherwise the only students I would catch are the ones with poor English skills (grammar switching from flawless to flawed and back again is a pretty good tell that the paragraph was written by somebody else).
- tyingq 5y agoI do agree that instructors hold a fair amount of responsibility for using the tool right. But the tool is shite. It misses some very basic stuff. Like "stuff in quotes followed by a footnote/citation" is copied, by definition, on purpose. It also notes things like missing commas as if it's 100% authoritative. Even though the passage in question passed Grammarly, Word, etc. There's no notion of nuance or suggestion, just "right/wrong".