3 ms·
Is there any human organization that is not making the world worse in one way or another? Its pretty much relative in any case, hardly purely evil or purely goo
by ekianjo 5y ago
Is there any human organization that is not making the world worse in one way or another? Its pretty much relative in any case, hardly purely evil or purely good unless you are very naive or very young.
- tolbish 5y agoPublic broadcasting/public radio seems like a pure public good. Along with the people working on disaster.radio [0] [0] https://disaster.radio/ https://disaster.radio/
- ekianjo 5y agopublic broadcasting? you mean state sanctionned propaganda disguised as news?
- dharmab 5y agoAre you sure you know what "public broadcasting" is? It's broadcasting funded by the public, mostly through private donations and some funding through competitive grants. EDIT: I see from your profile you're not in the US, which is probably the source of the confusion. Examples of Public Broadcasting are https://www.npr.org https://www.npr.org and https://www.pbs.org https://www.pbs.org.
- NateEag 5y agoAs a US citizen who used to listen to NPR daily, it may not be state-sanctioned, but it definitely had a propagandistic narrative tying together the reporting. Maybe not quite as strongly so as the NYT, but it was definitely there.
- esrauch 5y agoI'm curious what country you're from to have that point of view. In the US the public radio is extremely clearly not a state sanctioned propaganda; some of the corresponding private news corps are much more.
- berdario 5y agoNot the person you're responding to, but... I live in the UK, and the BBC is definitely propaganda. I also agree with you that private broadcasters can definitely be worse. OTOH, it's a vicious circle: you cannot fix society without fixing propaganda, and if the propaganda is any good, you cannot fix propaganda without fixing society (most people will lend an ear to it, believe it, parrot it, support it, work for it, etc.)... so we just have to learn to live with it :/
- dharmab 5y agoMost food banks are pretty easily in the "unequivocally good" category, unless you're a Malthusian. Charity Navigator is a great way to find the best-managed and highest-impact food banks.
- malwarebytess 5y agoI volunteer all the time at a food bank. A lot of the work is sorting the incoming goods. Much of this work is done by volunteers. As a result it isn't uncommon for spoiled food to accidentally be stocked and distributed to people. It is a rare but not infrequent occurrence to have someone get sick and report back to the food bank. Not unequivocally good! :]
- tooltower 5y agoFine. I'll settle for a net social good
- CobrastanJorji 5y agoAlways seems like it's the people doing the worst things that pull out this line. They also like "well, if I didn't do it, someone else would've, so it might as well be me." There are plenty of organizations that mostly do good. To pick the first example that comes to mind, Partners in Health.
- pieterk 5y agoOr if you’re very Apple. They didn’t start out as that organization per se, but there’s lots of things to be said about how they’re committing to being at least carbon neutral to the planet over the whole lifecycle of their products. They set 2030 as that goal, but I believe they’ll get there much earlier than that. Google just went from one extreme to the other, and it’s seen by many as driven by a focus on Ads. Edit: the FOSS Community with Linus at its helm could be seen as an organization that’s focused on making the software world a better place.
- underwater 5y agoThe assertion was that companies aren't unequivocally good. Apple are better than most, but still support Foxconn and terrible factory conditions, use their ecosystem to crush open competitors, and push planned obsolescence via software updates.