3 ms·
"I'd rather have a mode where regular DNS and centrally controlled DNS are compared, and you get a popup if they differ." Not sure about "mode" and "popup" as
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
"I'd rather have a mode where regular DNS and centrally controlled DNS are compared, and you get a popup if they differ."
Not sure about "mode" and "popup" as I am not a fan of browsers and GUIs but I have been comparing results from about 50 or so DoH providers. I use DoH without a browser to gather DNS data in bulk.
We all have a clear idea about what "censorship" means but as we go further down the rabbit hole of myriad third party, non-ISP DNS providers how do we distinguish between "filtering" and "censorship". Projects like OpenDNS made a business out of DNS filtering. Now we are seeing others trying to make a business out of filtering ads.
It is well-known from studies using different DNS vantage points (looking glass) that DNS-based censorship is active in some countries and also that the number of countries doing this is generally rising. On a personal level, I do see differences in results from different DoH providers. What really bothered me recently was one provider returning "0.0.0.0" for certain domains, I am guessing because they were websites that report on the online ad industry. I am OK if they want to exclude certain domains, but returning the network equivalent of "any address" is, IMO, not an acceptable way to block access.
Personally, I think relying wholly on third party DNS is a bad idea. It is a useful resource, it's good to have many sources of DNS data, but third party operated DNS caches will never be authoritative for any domain. These third parties are usually just more internet middleman who want to make money from being in the middle of users network traffic. We always need access to the authoritative servers for each domain. That's our "source of truth".
DoH can be useful because I can download DNS data in bulk over TCP using HTTP pipelining. I load bulk data into haproxy's memory via a map file and I never need to do a single remote lookup. I run an authoritative DNS server that just answers all queries with the address of the proxy. Even more, I can add or delete entries from the map without restarting the proxy. The map is just a simple two column text file. This makes monitoring changes in DNS easy.
While I do not need "modes" and "popups" or other GUI-style conveniences, I can build a "no DNS" system into an OS that boots from USB stick into memory, never touches "disk" (can pull out the USB stick) and runs on a wide variety of hardware.