3 ms·
What are you trying to do with an asteroid, and why does it need to be decently sized? Neither is relevant. You calculate mass fraction, i.e. for a ship to get
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
What are you trying to do with an asteroid, and why does it need to be decently sized? Neither is relevant.
You calculate mass fraction, i.e. for a ship to get to orbit using kerosene, the ship must be 97% made of fuel my mass.
If you have an antimatter ship, if you can produce, store, and 100% efficiently use antimatter and carry nothing else as your reaction mass and don't have issues with waste heat or radiation, your ship will need to be over 90% fuel by mass to maintain 1G acceleration for years.
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago> What are you trying to do with an asteroid, and why does it need to be decently sized? Neither is relevant. I'm using the asteroid for mass, to react with the antimatter. So, yeah, it's relevant. > If you have an antimatter ship, if you can produce, store, and 100% efficiently use antimatter and carry nothing else as your reaction mass and don't have issues with waste heat or radiation, your ship will need to be over 90% fuel by mass to maintain 1G acceleration for years. Yup. And it's exponential - if the non-fuel mass is 10% to be able to do 10 years, then to do 20 years, the non-fuel mass can only be 1%, and for 30 years it can only be 0.1%. That's why you need the asteroid.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoTaking antimatter fuel out of your carefully designed, failsafe magnetic containment tanks and putting it into a highly-volatile asteroid of doom (attached with what? Antimatter-immune rope that can pull a billion tonns at 1G?) does not mean the rocket equasion gives you a free pass. Its still the same formula, nothing has changed. Its combined weight of your ship and it's asteroids. All you are saying is "you need a big fuel tank"
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI'm saying approximately how big a fuel tank you need to refute your "you can't do it for decades" statement.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoSo how big is it? Is a "decently sized asteroid" 50 meters across? 5,000? 500,000? Thats 4 orders of magnitude range. Like I know what's a decently sized car, or a house, or a mountain