3 ms·
Careful framing of the purported “myth” is critical: > For one, while residents are moving out of state, they are not doing so at "unusual rates." Similarly, t
by rayiner 5y ago
Careful framing of the purported “myth” is critical:
> For one, while residents are moving out of state, they are not doing so at "unusual rates." Similarly, the research found no evidence of "millionaire flight" from California and notes that the state continues to attract as much venture capital as all other U.S. states combined, despite the recent exodus of Hewlett-Packard and Oracle.
Who is saying California is unattractive for rich people and venture capital? The people leaving are middle and lower income people.
- deregulateMed 5y agoAnd these people will be replaced by less experienced or less talented workers. I recently heard a low performer get hired at a FAANG company and wondered how this person managed to trick that company into hiring him.
- fumar 5y agoIs this satire? If it is, spot-on commentary.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoMaybe he was a sacrificial hire? Aren't some managers expected to cull the lowest relative performers every year?
- haswell 5y ago> Who is saying California is unattractive for rich people and venture capital? One potential source: this is a popular conservative talking point about the dangers of liberal government, and the "exodus" is often used as evidence to justify those talking points. "See, just look at California, they implemented <liberal policy I hate>, and everyone is leaving the state". This kind of viewpoint is rampant on places like /r/conservative, and is often followed by similar mischaracterizations of life in Chicago. This always fascinates me - it seems like people are actually excited about the perceived negative forces driving people out, because they feel it validates their viewpoints about certain policies, even when the evidence to support correlation (never mind causation) doesn’t seem to exist. I haven’t encountered much serious discourse about California being unattractive to people with means. Edit: I’ve upset some folks with this comment. I’m curious to know how/why.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Edit: I’ve upset some folks with this comment. I’m curious to know how/why. Any mention of politics tends to get downvoted, but in this case, the myth is in significant part a product of a political narrative. I don't know how we can avoid the subject. We can't talk about the Earth's orbit without discussing the Sun.
- chrisco255 5y agoIn a complex state with millions of people and perspectives, is it not possible that a large group of people from California do feel that way and do express those views when they move to other states?
- haswell 5y agoI absolutely think that is possible. I’m sure a combination of factors plays into this. My point was that when I’ve seen this come up, it’s almost always in the political context. That doesn’t exclude other possibilities, but does seem to be a major contributor to the “buzz” about this topic.
- rayiner 5y agoThe version of that argument I tend to see is more refined than that: https://www.nationalreview.com/magazine/2021/04/19/ https://www.nationalreview.com/magazine/2021/04/19/. National Review just had an entire issue on the subject. The thrust of the argument is that what made California great was that it was a great place to move and raise kids in the suburbs with lots of opportunities. The changes in California are hitting those people the hardest. And those people are in fact leaving: https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/01/09/not-the-golden-state-anymore-middle-and-low-income-people-leaving-california https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/01/09/not-the-golden-state-... The fact that California continues to be a great destination for young single engineers, venture capitalists, and H-1B workers for whom working at a California tech company is a ticket to staying in the US at all, isn’t responsive to that argument.
- snek_case 5y ago