3 ms·
If they still end up charging 15% for doing the same thing automated there hasn't been any meaningful economic progress. There's just concentration of wealth.
by pydry 5y ago
If they still end up charging 15% for doing the same thing automated there hasn't been any meaningful economic progress. There's just concentration of wealth.
If they can cut that 15% to 1% and this field ends up being competitive then sure.
But, they're probably going for a monopoly play here.
- crazygringo 5y agoIt doesn't matter if they're trying to go for a monopoly play here. Competitors would arise and there wouldn't be any inherent monopoly dynamics left. So of course the percentage will be cut. That's how competition works.
- pydry 5y agoHave you seen the fees airbnb charges?
- TeMPOraL 5y agoIt's a two-sided market, it's gonna be winner-takes-all.
- crazygringo 5y agoYou mean the way Lyft went out of business because Uber took it all, and then Uber raised their prices 5x?
- TeMPOraL 5y agoNo, the way it will happen when Uber, Lyft and their other rideshare competitors run out of investor money and become forced to actually turn a profit. Still, Uber is not sticky. Drivers aren't forced to use it exclusively (fun things would happen if they tried to pull it off, something something employees). Brokerage websites most likely will demand you don't post your apartment on multiple sites. This will encourage concentration.
- crazygringo 5y agoIt doesn't matter if a brokerage website is exclusive. Healthy competition between, say, 3 main ones means people looking for apartments will check those 3. Kind of like people looking for used textbooks will check eBay, Alibris, and Chegg. Of course there will be concentration, that doesn't mean it's going to be a monopoly. It's just going to be the usual 2 main competing companies with a 3rd slightly-different company -- your Coke, Pepsi and RC, or your AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile. It's the usual market pattern.
- pydry 5y agoLyft and Uber have already dialed down their competition with each other in many locations and raised prices. If theyre smart theyre probably already hammering out an (illegal) agreement of some kind and figuring out ways to disguise the price rise as a natural side effect of something innocuous. Did you really think investors were willing to sustain a 12 billion dollar loss for a shot at a 1% margin?
- crazygringo 5y ago> Lyft and Uber have already dialed down their competition with each other Citation needed. They've raised prices in order to be sustainable, but you're going to need to show some kind of actual evidence of collusion. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. We can't just assume conspiracy theories between publicly traded companies here. And who's talking about 1% margins? You're making that up. Healthy competition usually results in something like 10% margins. You don't need illegal agreements to get that.
- pydry 5y agoshrug they made losses of 15 billion dollars and all that would be required to stem future losses in what has become a stable duopoly is one conversation. I tend to assume the path of least resistance.
- crazygringo 5y agoThe path of least resistance is not going to prison. You realize that in publicly traded corporations decisions are made by whole teams of people? And that people talk? Word gets out, company gets fined more than they made, executives go to prison. The US actually prosecutes this stuff, the same way they vigorously prosecute insider trading. A couple of neighboring grocery stores can realistically collude to raise prices. Multinational public corporations, not so much.
- pydry 5y agoIt may be illegal but it's hard to prove collusion. It certainly doesnt require whole teams of people. It requires a few senior managers to be in on it. The just world hypothesis is a powerful thing.