5 ms·
It's a real bummer that the US doesn't recognize that human rights apply to all human beings.
by sneak 5y ago
It's a real bummer that the US doesn't recognize that human rights apply to all human beings.
- kube-system 5y agoLiterally speaking, the 4th Amendment is just a legal right. Most human rights declarations don't require warrants either, they're mostly much more loosely worded than legal rights documents.
- boomboomsubban 5y ago> The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, It specifically says that the natural right will not be violated, how is that a legal right?
- kube-system 5y agoThe constitution is a legal document that is formally upheld by the US legal system. Many of the ideas within it were derived from other places, but it, itself, is a codified legal document.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoIt is a legal document guaranteeing a natural right. The Bill of Rights doesn't codify much of anything, it lays out certain things further laws can't tread on without extraordinary permission granted.
- kube-system 5y agoIt guarantees much more than a natural right, and does so with the backing power of a legal institution. For example, the UDHR doesn't even mention the word "warrant", and it doesn't do anything to compel enforcement. The BoR is, by plain definition, a codification of rights. To codify means to make into law, which is what it is: a law, implementing the formal recognition rights... and it does so by making illegal specific abuses.
- jhgb 5y agoIt's a legal right because some kind of law (in this case the constitution) gives it to you.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoI quoted the Fourth Amendment, it is written in a way to clearly state it is not giving you rights. It is protecting the rights you already have.
- jhgb 5y agoPeople's rights are a collective agreement of the society, crazy superstitions of the past centuries about "God-given rights" notwithstanding.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoThat's not the way the US Bill of Rights frames it. It says that purely by existing people have certain rights, and society chooses which ones should be protected and which should be surrendered. By having means of communication, I naturally have the right to free speech. The government can only limit that freedom. It's supposed to be a way of showing that the government is subservient to the citizens, as it does not have the power to grant citizens rights. I doubt it's effective though, as most people seem to think the Constitution grants rights.
- jhgb 5y ago> It says that purely by existing people have certain rights Maybe that's just me, but that's way too abstract for me. Have planets and stars always had certain rights purely by existing as well? > and society chooses which ones should be protected Well in that case you could make the case that every single person has every single right anyone could possibly have and the society chooses a subset of these rights as actual laws. I guess this is a way to eat your cake and have it, too, since it makes the difference between my and your view unobservable.
- hacker187 5y agoAlso a bummer: that a legislative majority of US citizens care more about the rights of unborn than the born. Almost every conservative (and many centrist democrats) US citizen I asked unapologetically supports mass drone strikes. And so we've had thousands. Many strike entire homes, wedding parties, marketplaces, etc. Example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wech_Baghtu_wedding_party_airstrike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wech_Baghtu_wedding_party_airs...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- threatofrain 5y agoThe citizens of the world who believe in universal human rights should gather consensus with the world lest they have nothing to do but continue to talk about how much of a bummer things are on a HN forum. Of course, international rights also need international enforcement, since a right without enforcement is just a nice thought. Perhaps we'll also have a world order to enforce these rights.
- sneak 5y agoFortunately they're not mutually exclusive. Expressing discontent with the status quo is one prong of consensus gathering.
- threatofrain 5y agoIs the vision that after WW3 we'll be in search of a uniting philosophy and government to make sure natural human rights are codified and enforced?
- oliv__ 5y agoSeeing the current state of freedom and rights across the world, I'd much rather have to deal with my own national crooks than a worldwide organization purporting to fight for my rights
- wolverine876 5y ago> Of course, international rights also need international enforcement, since a right without enforcement is just a nice thought. Perhaps we'll also have a world order to enforce these rights. Universal human rights have exploded to be adopted by much of the world, without an international government. Rights are not just nice thoughts. Even oppressive governments don't have the resources to control everything everyone does (of course). Just adopting the outlook, just believing you are free will make you free to a great extent.
- veddox 5y agoYou have to distinguish between human rights and citizens‘ rights.
- sudosysgen 5y agoPerhaps, but the predominant rhetoric and narrative is that human rights are the topic of concern, not citizen rights. It's difficult to make the case that only citizens deserve rights without sliding into questionable ideologies.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoCitizens are groups of humans who decide on different subsets of rights. E.g. humans in Germany are not allowed to be educated while young outside of the buildings of the state.
- sudosysgen 5y agoSure, but that doesn't change the basic point - you can't use an argument for human rights to confer citizen-only rights. If you're the US government, and you're justifying your power by saying that you respect human rights, and then you do a bait-and-switch and provide citizen's rights but not human rights, you just lied. That being said, strictly speaking I disagree, citizens do not have full authority on rights and neither are all rights conferred to classes of citizens.
- fouric 5y agoThis is inflammatory, insubstantial, and I'm pretty sure it violates the HN guidelines.