4 ms·
Let us suppose that representation is off the table. What about subsidies and support? We expect, regardless of nationality, to get something in exchange for pa
by cratermoon 5y ago
Let us suppose that representation is off the table. What about subsidies and support? We expect, regardless of nationality, to get something in exchange for payment of taxes. We fund government programs from which we benefit, but also those we may not directly benefit from or even support.
Does anyone expect that churches, once taxed, will not, through the work of their members, demand, and get, government funds? Are people who advocate taxing the Catholic church prepared to accept that, as a result, some tax money will find it's way into programs expressly created to benefit the church? If government money flows to support institutions the church opposes, it will almost certainly flow to the church itself. Is that political situation tolerable to those who advocate taxing churches?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> What about subsidies and support? One of the reasons for the push is that Catholic institutions (particularly schools) already get subsidies and support. > Does anyone expect that churches, once taxed, will not, through the work of their members, demand, and get, government funds? They already do, through the work of their members and supporters. Making it more expensive to support churches at current levels before engaging in additional political activity won't increase their success at doing that.
- cratermoon 5y agoClearly I need to bow out of this conversation, because I'm speaking as someone living in the US familiar with US laws, and the discussion is taking a distinctly provincial turn. I'm not sure why discussing church-state relations only in terms of Canadian law is of much interest to HN, but I'll concede that I have nothing to contribute along those lines.