3 ms·
This article is another rehash of "businesses get better tax breaks than you do". I don't think this is very revelatory -- we already knew this. Also interest
by jedberg 5y ago
This article is another rehash of "businesses get better tax breaks than you do". I don't think this is very revelatory -- we already knew this.
Also interesting is this particular article is talking about carry forward losses. Regular people can carry forward losses too, it just doesn't happen very much because it only applies to investments. But if have a big investment loss, you can carry that forward as well. You can also depreciate your assets like Ballmer does. It's just that you probably don't have enough to deduct to get beyond the standard deduction.
The real problem with our tax code is that it favors capital over labor. Losses tied to capital can be written off, but losses tied to labor cannot (like the food, shelter, and clothing you need so you can live to work another day).
Imagine how our world would change if you could write off your rent, meals, and clothes. Anyone living paycheck to paycheck wouldn't pay any taxes at all. Of course it would also discourage savings, so we'd have to find a balance somewhere.
- kristjansson 5y ago> Losses tied to capital can be written off, but losses tied to labor cannot An even better word here is 'expenses'. Businesses pay tax revenue net of expenses, people pay tax on revenue, and Propublica is shocked - shocked! - by what businesses can count as expenses. I suppose there's an argument that standard exemption/deduction are an estimate of baseline expenses to sustain labor, and additional costs over that are consumption that shouldn't be allowed to be netted against revenue (labor income). Does one's _entire_ rent go toward sustaining their productive capacity, or does is some part of that accrue to personal enjoyment? Of course, for most workers, even the 12k deduction probably doesn't feel anywhere close to basic living expenses, It is nice to imagine a fairer system that would allow the high cost of living in most US cities to be reflected in the treatment of labor income, but that sounds like even more complexity to add to the tax code.