4 ms·
What does he expect for a site that serves his videos for free, not to mention recommends them to people as well to get a wider audience? "Sovereignty" is a bi
by crazygringo 5y ago
What does he expect for a site that serves his videos for free, not to mention recommends them to people as well to get a wider audience?
"Sovereignty" is a bizarre word here. It's a business deal. Nobody's ever "sovereign" in any exchange, it's either a good deal or not.
If he wants to pay for hosting himself, then go ahead, but no need to act like it's a question of "sovereignty". Nobody's a king here.
- phkahler 5y ago>> What does he expect for a site that serves his videos for free, not to mention recommends them to people as well to get a wider audience? Lets turn that around. YouTube is a huge content provider that has 100 percent of their content provided FOR FREE and they feel that they can "monetize" it any way they see fit. There needs to be some balance. If enough people leave like this, there will be a credible competitor to YouTube and they'll never get those people back. Better yet, self hosting and federated services will start to become a thing and that could be an existential threat to Google itself. But sure, they are free to do what they like on their platform. Doesn't mean it's always the best thing to do.
- crazygringo 5y ago> that has 100 percent of their content provided FOR FREE Not true. Creators can get paid for their video views and some make a living at it. Some of the content Google doesn't pay anything for, but tons of it (and most of the popular stuff) Google pays for on a per-view basis. It's not free to Google. > There needs to be some balance. That already is the balance, Google paying creators for the popular content.
- upofadown 5y agoThe business deal used to be good. Now there is a sovereignty problem. The free part is not relevant here. We can't help that Google is having problems monetizing a service by first providing an acceptable service and then later changing the terms of the deal. Perhaps their business model is unrealistic.
- crazygringo 5y agoGoogle isn't having problems monetizing... their business model is entirely realistic, in fact it's wildly successful. Perhaps the business deal was too good before, and now it's merely good? Previously it was "acceptable" for them to store and host your videos for zero cost and show them without ads, and now you think it's "unrealistic" for them to finally cover those costs with ads?
- Chris2048 5y ago> their business model .. wildly successful On what basis? They has an old model, build up the success of the platform, then changed the model. On what basis can we judge the new model successful versus the momentum of the old model?
- crazygringo 5y ago> On what basis? Literally the line that says "YouTube ads" in their quarterly report? 2020 Q1 was $4 billion, 2021 Q1 was $6 billion. [1] Seems like wild success to me. But, you know, keep checking for the next few quarters if you're convinced Google is killing their golden goose. They've got some pretty smart business analysts and product people over there though, I wouldn't bet against them. [1] https://abc.xyz/investor/static/pdf/20210428_alphabet_10Q.pdf https://abc.xyz/investor/static/pdf/20210428_alphabet_10Q.pd...
- Chris2048 5y agosure, but don't mind if I discount a pandemic year.
- lostmsu 5y agoPerhaps it would be useful for competition to require media platforms provide content creators a way out. E.g. a mandatory "redirect to my new site" option.