4 ms·
I wonder at what point we as internet users will decide that we're willing to pay for services in order to maintain more control? In the meantime I sympathize
by duxup 5y ago
I wonder at what point we as internet users will decide that we're willing to pay for services in order to maintain more control?
In the meantime I sympathize with folks who in a way have ground rules changed on them, but then again were using a free service where they were the product...
The internet is a weird place where we demand everything be free as just a baseline rule, and then complain when the product that we didn't pay for changes, or in some other cases just tries to turn a profit / be sustainable.
- numpad0 5y agoHTTP 402 being left unimplemented only seemed natural to me just a decade ago; today looks an incredibly stupid decision. How things change……
- acomjean 5y agoI didn't know what the HTTP 402 status code was: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Status/402 https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Status/402 Its payment required.
- daptaq 5y ago402 is not the issue, the issue is having a payment system that wouldn't just add an implicit dependency on some payment service.
- draw_down 5y agoMore control for whom? A content creator’s struggles with YouTube are only relevant to me to the extent that I am able to watch their videos. The monetization, rights, etc are between them. Not my monkeys, not my circus.
- abacadaba 5y agothe main holdup i think is truly effortless and secure, private, and widely accepted micropayments. there's plenty of stuff i'd be willing to pay for if it didn't involve creating yet another account and giving them my credit card info.
- jrd259 5y agoTed Nelson was very explicit on this point in his visionary book "Dream Machines".
- criddell 5y agoHow would it work with not creating an account? Low-friction payment methods are here. Apple and Google Pay for example work pretty well. But if I pay for access to something today, how do you know it's me when I return a year later and want access again? A good password manager can make creating an account almost effortless. Maybe that's part of the solution.
- phkahler 5y ago>> Apple and Google Pay for example work pretty well. But if I pay for access to something today, how do you know it's me when I return a year later and want access again? Yet another reason why identity verification by default would make the net better. No spam, easy payments, elimination of middle-men for many use cases.
- ghaff 5y agoOf course, now you're talking about essentially eliminating anonymity on the web which not everyone would want.
- ipsi 5y agoMaybe browsers should looking at adding a "create account" API or something? Similar to "Login with Apple ID", but instead password managers could hook into it and create an account semi-automatically. This could also allow automation of "user+sitename@domain.com"-style rules. I know that creating an account isn't adding _much_ friction, but there is some and I could see myself appreciating this.
- fouric 5y ago> How would it work with not creating an account? Notice that they said "yet another account" - I'm pretty sure that they're not objecting to the idea of creating a single account for the micropayments service, but instead creating a separate account for each individual service that they could instead use micropayments for. > A good password manager can make creating an account almost effortless. Maybe that's part of the solution. That was already excluded by their comment - "and giving them my credit card info" - wherein it's made clear that part of the problem is the proliferation of private data among a very large number of individual sites/services/systems. A password manager doesn't do anything at all to help secure your private information from these services that you would be signing up for.
- Workaccount2 5y agoProbably never. I'd venture that the overwhelming majority of users on the internet do not even understand the concept of the ad model, much less the downsides. To them the internet and everything on it is free (and what isn't free is just greed by the owner) and ads are these annoying thing that crop up everywhere.
- duxup 5y agoI fear you may be correct. Or maybe even that people just don't care about privacy enough to do a thing about it :(
- analognoise 5y agoSadly I think it's both: everything is free right, and what's the big deal with this privacy stuff anyway?
- Finnucane 5y agoIsn't that what commercial streaming services like CuriousityStream and Skillshare are trying to provide?
- TheRealDunkirk 5y ago> I wonder at what point we as internet users will decide that we're willing to pay for services in order to maintain more control? You can already do this at Vimeo. I guess we should look at how well they are doing with that. (That's not leading; I don't know.)
- wyldfire 5y ago> I wonder at what point we as internet users will decide that we're willing to pay for services in order to maintain more control? The non-free service will always be a smaller player IMO. But if there were a big enough bundle, people might see the value. A not-too-many-USD-per-year Youtube+LinkedIn+Facebook+Twitter web suite would be feasible IMO. Just imagine if it were seen as a public good and countries could fund it with a comparatively small per capita investment.
- wintermutestwin 5y agoI would pay a sub for YouTube due to the value provided if they, in turn, paid me for the data they have stolen from me. Of course, if I get to name my price in this "free market," they would be paying me far more than they could reasonably charge for YT. And really, why would I want to give money to an abusive company? I keep hearing this lament that everyone just wants stuff for free. I think it is a distraction from the current wild west where these surveillance companies are the ones getting high value data for petty baubles.
- duxup 5y ago> these surveillance companies are the ones getting high value data for petty baubles Because we give it to them. The end user's choices matter here.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoBut should the audience pay or the creators? I can pay a subscription to watch videos but the creators may choose another video hosting service. So this only works if it's a monopoly, or if the services agrees to create a federation. Looks like PeerTube is better suited for this than Youtube but who should I pay and how do hosting platforms pay each creator wherever they host their content?
- savingsPossible 5y ago"give" only in the technical sense. "did not turn off third party cookies" should not equate "authorized this company to log about every site I visit" (of course, if you are on youtube itself, that is another matter -- but you are replying to, I think, a more general comment about the two sides and the value they obtain/extract from each other)
- stickfigure 5y ago> I wonder at what point we as internet users will decide that we're willing to pay for services in order to maintain more control? You mean like this? https://www.youtube.com/premium https://www.youtube.com/premium
- ssivark 5y agoTorrents seem like the ideal solution for something like this? The infrastructure cost of hosting is shared by all those who find the content valuable. It also has a natural cache-like behavior where popular content will be highly seeded, while unpopular content drops out. Interestingly, Peertube seems to be backed by exactly such infrastructure.
- nathanyz 5y agoThis is a super important point. We as users control how we are treated on the Internet. We can choose to pay for content, or we can choose to exchange our time, data, buying habits, psychographics, etc, etc, etc in return for "free" services. The choice is ours...Pay or barter? Barter our time watching ads, or pay money that we earned elsewhere. Disclaimer: Founder of YouTube alternative where site owners who are tired of exchanging their traffic, and user data for free video hosting can pay affordable pricing just like they do for their web host, database host, and other services.