17 ms·
But it's not a smoking cessation product. It can be used effectively as such, but it's first and foremost a healthier substitute to smoking. People like to go
by TeMPOraL 5y ago
But it's not a smoking cessation product. It can be used effectively as such, but it's first and foremost a healthier substitute to smoking.
People like to go to both extremes wrt. vaping - "but it creates new addicts" vs. "but it's effective tool for breaking addiction", forgetting about the biggest benefit vaping brings: letting smokers who don't want to quit to keep smoking, without risking lung cancer.
I'm definitely against marketing vaping to non-smokers. But I'm fine with converting existing smokers to vaping without any talk about quitting, because smoking e-cigarettes is strictly better than smoking analog ones.
- wayneftw 5y agoYes, it is a smoking cessation product. It helps you cease smoking. Vaping is not smoking.
- rob74 5y agoOk, so it's a smoking cessation product if you take the definition strictly - but it doesn't do anything to get you off your nicotine addiction, which people usually mean by "smoking cessation product"...
- yCombLinks 5y agoYou've created your own definition and now expect us to accept it, which I don't.
- mullingitover 5y agoNicotine is the thing people obsess over, but there are far more harmful substances than nicotine in tobacco cigarettes (for example, radioactive elements Polonium-210 and lead-210), and there are MAOIs that make the nicotine in tobacco smoke far more addictive.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoAll the smokers I know want to quit smoking, not nicotine.. Smoking is 99% of the problem with cigarettes, and nicotine is 1%.
- moftz 5y agoA vape can be much cheaper than cigarettes and you get the benefit of not inhaling smoke and smelling like smoke. You can also begin reducing the amount of nicotine in your vape juice without reducing the amount of time you spend vaping. Most brands offer numerous levels of nicotine from something that's a little stronger than regular cigarette down to none.
- wayneftw 5y ago> Ok, so it's a smoking cessation product if you take the definition strictly... I do. > but it doesn't do anything to get you off your nicotine addiction, which people usually mean by "smoking cessation product"... OK but what does this have to do with expressing ourselves accurately?
- leereeves 5y ago> I'm definitely against marketing vaping to non-smokers. But I'm fine with converting existing smokers to vaping How can a society allow marketing vaping as a healthier way to smoke without allowing marketing that makes non-smokers think vaping is a healthy way to smoke? (Especially considering that the marketers are eager to market to non-smokers.)
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 5y agoHot take. Ban marketing/advertising? These are conversations that belong in a physicians office. Advertising is a scam on both sides and destroys instead of creates value for humanity. Historians will look back upon advertising the way many look back upon slavery.
- franga2000 5y agoIs it not already? Genuine question. In all of the coutries I'm familiar with, both smoking and vaping are illegal to advertise. Even alcohol in some cases, although more commonly it's allowed but strictly regulated (must be purely factual, no glorification, mandatory health disclaimer...)
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 5y agoBanned, in theory? Enforced? Nah. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/12/health/juul-vaping-lawsuit.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/12/health/juul-vaping-lawsui...
- smeej 5y agoRelated: Why is there talk about banning Juul from selling its products in the U.S. entirely, but no such conversation about banning any of the big tobacco companies from selling theirs? It's all about power. There are so many things it would be useful to quantify and compare: Does anybody know the difference between the percentage of non-nicotine users who begin smoking cigarettes and the percentage who begin vaping? It sounds like the percentage for vaping is higher, but how much higher? Is it as much higher as the risk of dangerous health complications smoking has over vaping? Never mind the question of why nicotine addiction is so dangerous it must be prevented on a federal level, but alcohol addictions aren't? How much more dangerous is nicotine than alcohol?
- egeozcan 5y agoHealthier substitute to smoking practically means a smoking cessation product. Impossible meat, likewise, is a meat "cessation" product. If impossible meat makes vegans start eating burgers, you can't just argue "well, it's still better than meat". > I'm definitely against marketing vaping to non-smokers. But this is the whole point, they do attract non-smokers. They should explicitly detract them instead.
- dgfitz 5y ago> Impossible meat, likewise, is a meat "cessation" product. No it’s not. Meat isn’t addictive. People don’t “quit” meat and develop a habit of impossible burgers. People don’t wake up every morning feeling shitty about enjoying meat. I fully support vegan and vegetarian lifestyles. To compare tobacco to meat is foolish.
- michaelt 5y agoI suppose in a very literal sense, if you replace addiction A with addiction B, you could say that B is an A cessation product. But by that logic, smoking could be called a weight loss product. Other people have a more complex definition, which precludes cigarettes from being considered a health product, despite their appetite-suppressing properties.
- thebean11 5y ago> smoking could be called a weight loss product And it was! The difference is that smoking isn't really healthier than obesity, so it's not a very good way to lose weight overall.
- dude187 5y agoIf you can drop 100+ lbs by smoking half a pack a day, I guarantee you'll be a lot healthier overall. Not saying you actually _would_ lose all that weight, but it's not like it's a binary between "smoking" and "not smoking". Frequency and amount matters, but the it's pretty much impossible to approach the subject in our society with any sort of objectivity or science.
- Semaphor 5y ago> letting smokers who don't want to quit to keep smoking, without risking lung cancer. I started smoking when I was 18 (2004), picked up some of the first vapes in 2009 (they were horrible), and finally stopped smoking in 2012. But I don’t want to stop vaping. I don’t like the modern mainstream ecigs like juul (I mix my own liquid and build my own coils on a dual 18650 battery device), but I’m just glad that vaping exists, because, if all my fruitless attempts at quitting were any indication, otherwise I’d still be smoking a pack a day.
- boredtofears 5y agoIs it accurate to say you quit smoking when you've really just switched the device that delivers the substance you're addicted to?
- yCombLinks 5y ago100% accurate, he didn't say he wanted to quit being addicted to nicotine. He wanted to quit smoking, which he has done.
- boredtofears 5y agoYou haven't really overcome your main addiction in that case though. I don't think that people colloquially interpret that as "quitting smoking" when that term gets used in this context, even if the meaning is literal.
- yCombLinks 5y agoI think people have mixed definitions, but I really think smokers just want to avoid the lung cancer and emphysema. It's not my place to judge them as failures because they don't meet my criteria of not being addicted to nicotine.
- rsynnott 5y agoBut is that the _point_? I think many people are pretty much okay with being addicted to nicotine if it's not going to kill them.
- ReGenGen 5y agoIts easy to forget that heart-disease kills as many smokers as Cancer. Vaping is still ingesting mystery compounds & heavy metals directly into the blood stream for the body's immune system to freak out on. https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/health_effects/tobacco_related_mortality/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/heal... https://www.jhsph.edu/news/news-releases/2018/study-lead-and-other-toxic-metals-found-in-e-cigarette-vapors.html https://www.jhsph.edu/news/news-releases/2018/study-lead-and...
- hyper0perator 5y agoThis is why all fast food needs to be heavily regulated by FDA and only available via prescription to limit abuse.
- wolverine876 5y agoIs there a history of fast food as a leading cause of death?