4 ms·
Copper is good for electric vehicles but aluminium is a decent substitute for most applications if it was to become super expensive.
by HPsquared 5y ago
Copper is good for electric vehicles but aluminium is a decent substitute for most applications if it was to become super expensive.
- rini17 5y agoFor household wiring it's not so decent as it creeps, which causes arcing and fires. For other uses, wherever aluminium could be substituted, it already was, such as underground power wiring. However, there is development in carbon nanotubes, in the lab they already make wires on par with aluminium, so hopefully that will work out.
- HPsquared 5y agoArcing isn't a problem if the proper manufacturing processes are used (crimped connections basically).
- rini17 5y agoSure, but crimping is additional work.
- Nasrudith 5y agoCarbon nanotubes while wonderous are not only expensive to manufacture but also seem to have issues with being asbestos-like despite their wonderous properties. I think automobiles may be a wrong application there although not as bad as break pads of the stuff.
- Robotbeat 5y agoThe asbestos fear only applies to powder/chopped CNTs. But in typical fiber form (yarns and such), it’s not a hazard. It doesn’t exfoliate easily like asbestos does and so has no more risk than carbon fiber or fiberglass. The cost for good CNTs is insane, though.
- elihu 5y agoIn some ways, it's better: lower weight relative to the current-carrying capacity. If I understand correctly, the main issue with aluminum is getting the connections right so that oxidation isn't an issue. If engineered correctly it shouldn't be a problem. Aluminum-wound motors are apparently also a thing, though (like with aluminum power cables) they tend to be physically larger than copper-wound motors for the equivalent amount of power.
- pfdietz 5y agoOverhead electric power lines are typically aluminum-wrapped steel. They are not volume limited, so aluminum is better and cheaper than copper.
- hinkley 5y agoThe aluminum carries the current, the steel is for support (tensile strength). How do they keep galvanic action from eating the whole assembly? I've never been clear on that bit.
- kortex 5y agoYeah, it's great for long haul like high tension wires, not so great for houses and electromechanical contrivances. Prone to oxidation/corrosion, so you have to usually use special lugs, or wire nuts filled with this goop. I could be mis-remembering but I also feel like it's more prone to whiskers/pest when soldered to boards, especially lead-free mixes. Either way, ends have to be crimped, so that's more steps. Just generally more annoying and expensive to work with than copper.
- Robotbeat 5y agoThe Model 3 actually uses aluminum cabling in some places (I think the main cable between the battery and the motor/controller assembly). In certain applications where weight is at a greater premium than volume, it can actually be superior to copper as its resistivity divided by density is lower than copper. (BTW, lithium is even slightly better on that metric than aluminum, although it oxidizes extremely rapidly so has to be carefully protected, making it impractical). Extremely long-term, sufficiently high quality graphene or carbon nanotubes can theoretically have higher mass-specific resistivity than copper or even aluminum. But in practice, CNTs and graphene have much worse electrical conductivity due to defects and the need to conduct between tubes/crystal regions/bundles.