4 ms·
I work in vision and I still have not heard a compelling case for Facial Recognition. There's useful things like iPhone unlock (similarly applied other places)
by godelski 5y ago
I work in vision and I still have not heard a compelling case for Facial Recognition. There's useful things like iPhone unlock (similarly applied other places) and identification systems. But the potential for abuse is just far too high in my mind. They say don't give powers to Mr. Rodgers that you wouldn't want Hitler to inherit. This is one of those powers. The good is things we can still do easily with other systems. The bad is a 1984 dystopia (also see the recent HN article about Tencent[0]. Why is no one here concerned about cameras scanning children... That's just inappropriate pictures waiting to be leaked). Crime has been going down. Terrorism is extremely rare. Pareto exists.
Like the upside here is if Mr. Rogers is in power you can unlock your iPhone and (if everything works perfectly... good luck?) you can get on an airplane ~1 minutes faster. But if Hitler is in power you have modern Phrenology (which we're already seeing).
What am I missing here? What is the great use case that warrants this?
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27755853 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27755853
- throwawaygh 5y agoI guess what you’re missing is that in either case there’s a juicy Total Addressable Market. Sad, but there’s enough greedy talent and capital that your calculus doesn’t matter.
- godelski 5y agoWhile I don't disagree with you, I think we can have better conversations on HN. Honestly I would love to hear from someone with a different opinion than me. I really do want to hear the counter argument. But this is also the technology that made Joseph Redmon[0] (creator of YOLO) leave vision research. We can have ethical discussions. We should have ethical discussions. And different opinions are how we learn. And I do think HN is one of those places to have these ethical conversations. [0] https://pjreddie.com/ https://pjreddie.com/
- throwawaygh 5y agoI hope you find a satiating interlocutor, but I think the most obvious explanation is probably the most correct one in this case. I know this theory doesn't exactly satiate one's intellectual curiosity, but sometimes the truth is boring.
- godelski 5y agoI mean I agree, but with how prevalent this is and how profitable it is, I would imagine there's someone selling the technology. Especially here. I really do want to hear their opinions and have mine challenged. Maybe there's something I don't see and I'm overly paranoid. Hopefully we'll see some dissenting opinion.
- PradeetPatel 5y agoI suspect that this kind of technology is already in use by authoritarian regimes with more diverse and relaxed ethical standards when it comes to surveillance.
- tfigment 5y agoDo some research on China and the Uyghurs and make your own call on if that is currently happening.
- godelski 5y agoWhile that's prolific it isn't like we aren't doing it in other parts of the globe. Highlight China, but highlight Europe and the US too.
- gpvos 5y ago> Facial recognition technology has been widely implemented in contemporary China and has become an integral part of people's daily life. (2020) https://www.taylorwessing.com/en/insights-and-events/insights/2020/05/china---facial-recognition-and-its-legal-challenges https://www.taylorwessing.com/en/insights-and-events/insight...
- _jal 5y agoHumans seem to have to try out every bad idea at least once, usually more than once. I hate to be pessimistic, but I don't see how it doesn't become ubiquitous very soon, with all the downsides ubiquitous surveillance are going to lead to.
- howaboutnope 5y agoWhen this stuff fully blooms it won't have a "downside", because that would imply some other thing of which that downside is a side. It will kill any resemblance of humans, and enabling it, nay, failing to fight it tooth and nail, is ultimately more heinous than all the crimes it might prevent combined. I don't care to speculate about outcomes. Optimistic or pessimistic, it always presumes a lack of agency. I just can't bring myself comment like a bystander or a fortune teller on something that is still ongoing and that I, like all people here, am involved in.
- prox 5y agoIt’s even much simpler : bigshot from security company visits director from school. Director feels important, bigshot can make coin. Both make a case to improve security (how can you turn that down) and a lot of networking and project is being done so People Look Busy. A lot of it is just buzz and network effect with little long term thought going into it.