5 ms·
Lots of fodder in this article, but this one stood out to me: "The school district originally purchased AnyVision after a mass shooting in 2018, with hopes tha
by tyingq 5y ago
Lots of fodder in this article, but this one stood out to me:
"The school district originally purchased AnyVision after a mass shooting in 2018, with hopes that the technology would prevent another tragedy."
I'm curious how facial recognition would prevent a mass shooting. Is there some database of faceprints of known future mass shooters?
- godelski 5y agoYou don't. All it does is help track their location, after you have identified them. Unless we want to turn back to using phrenology...
- cartoonworld 5y agoI'll bet an image processor that can recognize guns and gunfire and dead people would be even better. I suspect that people are drawn to "The Bourne Supremacy" look and feel of their command center, just behind the parent-teacher conference whiteboard.
- godelski 5y agoModern systems have a lot of problems and you get a lot of false positives. But honestly let's think about it more. If you can walk through a crowd with a visible gun, it's pretty unlikely that you'll be able to identify one with a camera. So if you only see the guns when they are drawn, well I'm not convinced this is meaningfully different because now the gun is being announced. I have serious reservations about using gait analysis for determining carrying weapons. I do want to draw attention to Destin from Smarter Every Day's gun detection system[0], where he even mentions part of the above situation. Maybe this could accelerate police response and automate it, but this honestly sounds like an over engineered system. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lh0x54GC1sw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lh0x54GC1sw
- jaclaz 5y agoI would add that even IF the technology allowed to "scan" a crowd and actually detect instantly and reliably a (visible) gun, what "remedies" do you have handy? I mean, it is not like at any school there is (or can be) a sort of SWAT team on alert and capable of an intervention in - say - 5 minutes. And - cannot say on the specific 2018 shooting at that school - from what I understand the typical sequence is: 1) someone enters a school (or church, etc.) with a gun 2) as soon as a suitable target is within firing range, the shooting starts and there is no more than 1, 2 or 3 minutes between #1 and #2 above, if the detection of the gun happens before (let's say outside when the shooter is approaching the building) you can maybe have a couple minutes more time. And - even if you actually had this fast intervention armed team ready - can you only imagine the risks of false alarms/incidents with perfectly innocent people, it cannot possibly work. Besides, there is no real need for facial recognition in this scenario, i.e. anyone, no matter who he/she is, should be detected if carrying a gun.
- 34679 5y agoI agree there's no need for facial recognition in this scenario and I'm not an advocate for its use, but think of how many times you can point a gun at someone and pull the trigger in 30 seconds. With each shot potentially representing a life, a couple minutes really would matter.
- jaclaz 5y agoSure, but what is "normal" or "average" intervention time from the moment the police is alarmed? I would guess something between 10 and 15 minutes at the very least (not counting the hypothesis of a local presence of policemen or military personnel). If what you want to prevent is that kind of unconditional mass shooting this doen't seem to be effective, by the time the police (early alerted by the automatic system) arrives, the shooter will very likely have fired all the ammunitions and already killed all the people that happened to be at range.
- ALittleLight 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- HelloNurse 5y agoIt's a convenient excuse. Facial recognition against school shooters is the high school counterpart of email interception against child porn.
- xphx 5y agoI believe the questionable rationale there is that it helps to identify suspended students whose presence is assumed to be dangerous. “The mission creep issue is a real concern when you initially build out a system to find that one person who’s been suspended and is incredibly dangerous, and all of a sudden you’ve enrolled all student photos and can track them wherever they go[.]”
- godelski 5y agoYou're not going to identify anyone unless you already have them in your system. Which opens up a whole other can of worms.
- xphx 5y agoYes, the stated original requirement to "find that one person who’s been suspended and is incredibly dangerous" does presuppose that the dangerous person is already in the system and you're just trying to find them. I don't personally find the rationale persuasive, I'm just answering the question how it could possibly be considered useful.