3 ms·
A lot of these points aren't actually contradictions. Examples: > “SARS-CoV-2 is not that dangerous” and “SARS-COV-2 is so good at making humans sick that it w
by josephcsible 5y ago
A lot of these points aren't actually contradictions. Examples:
> “SARS-CoV-2 is not that dangerous” and “SARS-COV-2 is so good at making humans sick that it was clearly engineered.”
It's perfectly possible for a disease to have low lethality but high transmissibility.
> “A ~1% death rate from COVID is not a big deal” and “an extremely rare (<0.001%) nonfatal side effect from a vaccine is a very big deal.”
This incorrectly assumes that you'll definitely get COVID if you don't get the vaccine. Also, deaths from COVID are concentrated in demographics different from where deaths from vaccine side effects are.
> “An observational study of ~30 people is enough to justify giving hydroxychloroquine for COVID” and “A randomized, blinded placebo-controlled trial of ~30,000 people is not large enough to justify giving the vaccine.”
There should be a higher standard for drugs given to the entire world population than for ones only given to those who have a severe case of a disease.
----
And a lot of the other ones, while they are indeed contradictory, are basically straw men. Examples:
> “If a 75-year-old with pre-existing conditions gets COVID and dies from pneumonia 4 days later, COVID was not the true cause” and “if a 75-year-old with pre-existing conditions gets the vaccine and dies from pneumonia 4 days later, the vaccine was definitely the true cause.”
The complaint I've heard is that the former is counted as a COVID death, but the latter is not counted as a vaccine death. "You can't have it both ways" itself goes both ways.
> “Most COVID cases are false positives” and “the case fatality rate is overestimated.” (If there were, in fact, fewer true COVID cases due to false positives, that would make the case fatality rate much higher.)
While I've repeatedly heard the claim that most COVID deaths weren't actually caused by COVID, I've never heard the claim that most COVID diagnoses are false positives. In fact, what usually gets claimed is that there's way more cases than diagnoses.