2 ms·
to be "self contradictory" the self word must apply. So these statements have to be understood to be articulated if not at the same time (the ideal) then by the
by ggm 5y ago
to be "self contradictory" the self word must apply. So these statements have to be understood to be articulated if not at the same time (the ideal) then by the same people.
The contradiction here is that the same people espouse contradictory views, seeing both as butressing their view.
That statements contradict each other is not unusual. Sometimes in the social domain, the "facts" are opinions. These tend to be oppositional (contradictory) from the same underlying information which is the underlying factual basis. But, are espoused by different people. Thats not the kind of contradiction here: This one, is the bizarre world of the people who can hold two oppositional "facts" (questionable) at the same time, and BOTH justify (questionable) their point of view.
For the other kind of contradiction:
I think C19 is "perfectly" adapted to invade human hosts. Does this mean I think its manufactured? No. I see this as evolution. But from the same belief, "its perfect" an oppositional view goes to "its TOO perfect" and then goes to "because its SO perfect, it must be manufactured AHA"
Was my use of the word "perfect" unwise? Yes. But, this is none the less what I think. Like many things in Evolution, its outcome is a messy, minimum-necessary achievable function of gene expression and gene mutation which arrived at a place well suited to modern mankind as a host, and with the right biomechanical behaviours (how fatal, how long it persists as an aerosol, how infectious it is, how long it survives, none of which require "intentionality" so behavuour is also perhaps the wrong word here...) to spread wide. From the virus' perspective, this is a pretty good outcome. No human gain-of-function agency is neccessary to do this: just, statistics, and a lot of virus.
For somebody deeply wedded to Lab-made, the same thing is "evidence" of need of mans hand. Go figure.