4 ms·
We homeschooled. Whenever we worried about socialization, we grabbed our kids, dragged them into the bathroom, and beat them up for their lunch money. I'm jok
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
We homeschooled. Whenever we worried about socialization, we grabbed our kids, dragged them into the bathroom, and beat them up for their lunch money.
I'm joking, but the point is, socialization in public school can take some horrible forms. (At least, it can in the US. Maybe schools in Australia are more sane.) That socialization isn't necessarily a good match for adult society, either, or even for university.
Socialization is still a concern. But socialize your children to adult society. They don't need to be socialized to public school society.
- actfrench 5y agoExactly. One out of five students report being bullied at school. https://www.pacer.org/bullying/info/stats.asp https://www.pacer.org/bullying/info/stats.asp Also a great piece in the Atlantic about how Black families are opting out of school due to institutionalized racism. https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2015/02/the-rise-of-homeschooling-among-black-families/385543/ https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2015/02/the-ri... A film I really like on this topic is Class Dismissed. It shows the journey of two girls who leave school and it's really amazing to watch them relax, get more at ease with themselves and make friends over the course of the film.
- uoaei 5y agoHaving been one of those kids "socialized into adult society", I was robbed of both my childhood and my serotonin. Children are indeed human beings...
- Benjamin_Dobell 5y agoI'm truly sorry to hear this. This is one such concern that I have. Do you think this comes down to the "adult society" you're being integrated into? If you don't mind my asking, do you think you know the motivation for the way you were raised/educated in the manner you were raised? I imagine there are a wide variety of reasons as to why parents home school, and that the outcomes vary significantly based upon those motivations.
- sparrish 5y agoI wish I could upvote this one a dozen times. My homeschooled kids can't communicate in emoji-talk, it's true. But they easily interact with both adults and other homeschooled children on both small-talk and meaningful conversational levels. That's more valuable in the long run.
- LanceH 5y agoI tutored home schooled kids for years (and many other kids and college students as well). I'm sure some of it is selection bias of those who reach out to a tutor in the first place, but I strongly disagree that homeschooled kids are socially stunted (agreeing with parent's comment). Rather, they seem to be quite capable of interacting at a far more mature level than their public school peers.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoIt works both ways. I am socially stunted and I went to public school in old country ( same issues really ). Sometimes I would argue it is because I went to public school, but my siblings are normal so maybe its just bad luck on my part.
- watwut 5y agoWhy do people hate emoji so much?
- throwaway_hs 5y agoThrowaway for obvious reasons. I'd caution you against getting too smug about this outlook. > Socialization is still a concern. But socialize your children to adult society. They don't need to be socialized to public school society. I was homeschooled and my parents explicitly went for this approach. It's a great way of turning out a materially successful miserable loner; perfect adult-pleasers who've never had real friends. You may think you're only cutting them off from bullying or emojispeak or whatever, but what you're really eliminating are opportunities to learn the dynamics of peer relationships. And no, socialization with other homeschooled kids doesn't count. Parents tend to vastly underestimate the importance of cultural fluency in the formation of peer relationships, and I think that's a tragic detriment to a lot of kids, especially the ones (like me) who internalize the sort of bullshit elitist attitudes that often inform non religious decisions to homeschool. And yes - my parents weren't religious and were highly educated on all the trendiest homeschooling topics. I'm obviously fairly steamed about this and deeply personally biased, so take my words with a grain of salt. This isn't intended as a personal attack in any sense.
- abnry 5y ago> the importance of cultural fluency in the formation of peer relationships Fluency in the culture is crap. Are we really supposed to be glad our kids know all the Cardi B songs?
- throwaway_hs 5y agoIf that's what their friends are talking about over the lunch table, then absolutely. Or, do you let your taste in music dictate your kids' social horizons?
- abnry 5y agoIt's not the music, it is the soft-core (if even) pornography. Just because "everyone is doing it" does not make it worth doing just to fit in.
- 5y ago
- ska 5y ago> But socialize your children to adult society. They don't need to be socialized to public school society. They don't need to be socialized to any particular public school society, but they do need to be socialized to the society of children. This is not adult society, and the difference is important. Sibling relationships are important but necessarily unusual, it's also necessary to go beyond this. If you try to inculcate adult society only in your children, I think you are doing them a great disservice.