5 ms·
School in general should be modularized so that you can pick your own path. It isn't necessary or sensible to think that every student will or should be at the
by musicale 5y ago
School in general should be modularized so that you can pick your own path. It isn't necessary or sensible to think that every student will or should be at the same point in every subject. The predictable result is that some students are bored as they are held back while others become frustrated as they fall hopelessly behind. Usually the latter are punished (if not publicly shamed) with bad grades simply for having less experience with the material and/or taking longer to master it for the first time.
"Tracking" was supposed to mitigate this to some extent, but it tends to be a) used across the board for multiple subjects and b) used as a means of sorting students into winners (who are richly rewarded with status and additional opportunities) and losers (who are deprived of rewards and benefits rather than offered additional help and assistance.)
Universities use a modular approach to great effect: you can usually take any course (even graduate courses) if you've completed the prerequisites. And there are multiple ways of fulfilling graduation requirements.
A limitation of the university approach is that for a given course in a given term, everyone in the course is usually still in lock-step. Sometimes this is mitigated by offering multiple versions of a course with different time scales (usually an "accelerated" version for people who are familiar with the material and/or want to devote more time per week.)
- weimerica 5y agoDo US schools tend to not allow for the "university" style course selection? In mine, which is all I really know, I was allowed to double-up on certain subjects, e.g. biology and chemistry side-by-side such that I completed all required courses in three years rather than the traditional four.
- rootusrootus 5y agoIt's pretty typical to have flexibility in scheduling. Some classes are mandatory for a particular grade level, the rest is prerequisite-based. At my local school, there was an extra early bird period in the morning if you wanted to take an extra class. We could also take classes from the local community college and have them count as both high school credit and college credit (today, the high school I went to has moved and is now sharing a property line with the community college, so it makes it very easy for students to go back and forth). My niece just graduated from high school two years ago and she's pretty close to finishing her bachelor's, because she had earned a lot of college credit already. For motivated students it really works out great.
- Jtsummers 5y agoIf hours are available, you can do that. Many US schools fill your day with mandatory courses and it’s hard to get an open hour for that. My second high school had an 8-class day which did allow for that option, if the classes were available without conflict. My first had a 7-class day and as a freshman I was told I couldn’t take Spanish unless I wanted to skip lunch (which I didn’t).
- dahfizz 5y agoMy highschool was similar to my college - there was a collection of required courses that covered all subjects, and there were electives you could choose from. In high school, the majority of your schedule was in required classes. In college, the vast majority was in major courses / electives.
- jcranmer 5y agoEvery school district can choose on its own what to do, so there's going to be intense variability and generalization is difficult. For my school district, the general tendency is that you had a "core" of mandatory classes where your choice was at best "do you want the hard or easy version of the class", although math in particular was tracked somewhat more independently of grade level. In addition, there is a set of elective slots, and degree requirements might strongly push you to certain electives (in particular, foreign language elective requirements are probably pretty common). Doubling-up on two sciences in one year wouldn't be normally possible, at least on the standard end-of-year sign-up-for-the-next-grade forms, but it is possible to do so if you bitch long and hard enough at a school counselor for special dispensation.
- swordsmith 5y agoThis was possible while I was in high school -- I was able to take Bio, Chem, Physics, and Calculus in the same year. However, this is no longer possible now for my younger siblings enrolling at the same public high school. Apparently the school now put much more strict limit on pre-requisite and what classes students can take at which year. There is now much less flexibility. This is not due to significantly increased student body size , but mainly for "equity" in education outcomes -- i.e. holding back the advanced students to accommodate the less advanced students. It makes very little sense, but that is California!
- jxramos 5y agoThis is fascinating, a parent can't rely on their own experience at a school they previously attended to estimate what to expect their own children would get from a given institution. Every generation always faces a new set of challenges, nothing formulaic to life.
- dahfizz 5y agoI agree to an extent, but the purpose of primary education is to provide a foundation of knowledge. We already struggle with the general population understanding statistics they hear on the news, or knowing how the government works. If most people opt out of basic math classes, society will be worse off.
- vehementi 5y agoA middle ground is requiring those courses but letting students choose when. Further to the obvious absurdity of everyone learning at the same speed, is the idea of everyone being equally interested and enthusiastic about every topic at the same time as everyone else. Let me go on a History shtick and then get my math together and then...
- jackson1442 5y agoI don’t think that would necessarily work because some of the subjects deeply integrate with one another. For example, English and math have huge crossover because English classes are about being able to convey ideas and you need to have a strong grasp of English to succeed in, say, a statistics class. I think if we could fine-tune instruction to skill levels, while still requiring a strong foundation in each subject, we would be much better off in the education scene.
- em-bee 5y agoi believe this correlation is more accidental than planned. i doubt that there is anyone who can claim to know exactly how much schooling in your native language is necessary before you can successfully pass a statistics class. i believe the reverse is true. taking a statistics class will advance your language skills, because you learn a lot more by application than by theory. and there is no reason that these language skills need to be learned in isolation before you can apply them. so maybe this slows down your learning for a bit, but even that is hardly provable because of different learning speeds of each student which likely vary far more than than the variation that language classes or the lack thereof would introduce. actually, the whole concept of classes for your native language doesn't make sense in this context. learning your native language permeates everything. you learn language in every class, be it math, biology, sports or whatever. a dedicated native language class at best fills in gaps such as learning grammar, linguistics and literature. but it is not, and should not be a prerequisite to learning anything else. the situation is a bit different when the language being used to teach is not your native language. a certain foundation in the language is necessary before you can follow classes, so a number of language classes are a prerequisite in that case