4 ms·
Unlikely. Remember that "taxation without representation is tyranny" was a catchphrase from the Revolutionary War. As soon as they are taxed, they will have a r
by cratermoon 5y ago
Unlikely. Remember that "taxation without representation is tyranny" was a catchphrase from the Revolutionary War. As soon as they are taxed, they will have a right to representation.
- gizmo385 5y agoDo their US congregants not have the same level of representation that all citizens living in a state have?
- frumper 5y agoU.S. Churches tax exempt status is typically as a 501c3 non-profit and that strictly forbids direct political activity. Removing the 501c3 designation would mean that they no longer have a reason to refrain from direct political activity. A Church does not specifically need to be a 501c3 organization to be tax exempt, but it makes things quite a bit easier for several reasons so most choose to go this route.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> U.S. Churches tax exempt status is typically as a 501c3 non-profit and that strictly forbids direct political activity. No, it doesn't. It prohibits direct or indirect campaign activity (a prohibition which, in the case of Churches, is widely flouted and for which enforcement is near no existent), but allows a variety of notionally non-campaign political activity (which, also, is a fictitious distinction, and essentially all activity undertaken of this type is direct activity targeted at advancing particular candidates or parties electoral prospects, and tends to be particularly focussed around particular elections.) > Removing the 501c3 designation would mean that they no longer have a reason to refrain from direct political activity. Removing the 501(c)3 designation would mean that not only was the church so affected no longer tax exempt but donations to it would no longer be tax deductible, so it would need substantially more donated dollars, each of which would cost donors more (because of the lack of deductibility), just to be where it was status quo ante. So they'd have less money to spend on the political activity they already freely engage in. > A Church does not specifically need to be a 501c3 organization to be tax exempt It does for donations to be tax deductible; also, “churches” are an enumerated subtype of 501(c)3, but not of other tax exempt categories, so while being a church ipso facto qualified you for 501(c)3 status (and for exceptions to some rules applicable to other 501(c)3 orgs) if you are willing to abide by the subset of rules actually enforced on churches in that classification, it doesn't automatically qualify you for any other tax exempt status. Of course, all this is irrelevant to the article which is about Canada, which has not yet become a region of the United States subject to the US tax code.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Remember that "taxation without representation is tyranny" was a catchphrase from the Revolutionary War. As soon as they are taxed, they will have a right to representation. No, they won’t. One, because that wasn’t a catchphrase of Canada’s nonexistent Revolutionary War. Two, because catchphrases aren’t legally binding. And three, because the catchphrase involved referred to central government taxation of the population of a distinct local jurisdiction, whose citizenry had representation in the local, but not central, government. All the citizens affected already are fully represented in the central government of Canada. So, the non-binding foreign catchphrase at issue wouldn't even suggest a representation gap in the case under discussion if the complaint it was making was treated as a binding rule applicable to the case, which it very much is not.
- cratermoon 5y agoLet us suppose that representation is off the table. What about subsidies and support? We expect, regardless of nationality, to get something in exchange for payment of taxes. We fund government programs from which we benefit, but also those we may not directly benefit from or even support. Does anyone expect that churches, once taxed, will not, through the work of their members, demand, and get, government funds? Are people who advocate taxing the Catholic church prepared to accept that, as a result, some tax money will find it's way into programs expressly created to benefit the church? If government money flows to support institutions the church opposes, it will almost certainly flow to the church itself. Is that political situation tolerable to those who advocate taxing churches?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> What about subsidies and support? One of the reasons for the push is that Catholic institutions (particularly schools) already get subsidies and support. > Does anyone expect that churches, once taxed, will not, through the work of their members, demand, and get, government funds? They already do, through the work of their members and supporters. Making it more expensive to support churches at current levels before engaging in additional political activity won't increase their success at doing that.