7 ms·
This is great and all of it true, but the needs of these companies are counter to the goals presented here. Ad funded products need to steal time and attention
by echelon 5y ago
This is great and all of it true, but the needs of these companies are counter to the goals presented here.
Ad funded products need to steal time and attention to be profitable. Apple might be in a position to do something, but Facebook, Twitter, and Google depend on ad revenue. Even subscription companies like Netflix are hyper focused on engagement.
I was daydreaming yesterday about a national mandate to shut down social media on the first of every month. (Phone calls and texting are okay, but absolutely nothing else.) Something like that will never happen, but I think the world would collectively realize what this stuff is doing to us if we had to step away.
We're all addicted and distracted.
- DevKoala 5y agoIt would never happen because social media would convince users to vote against their own interests. Like Facebook did with the Apple debacle.
- agency 5y agoYeah to be honest this feels like a Googler trying to deal with their guilty conscience by starting a "movement" that fundamentally cannot go anywhere because it runs entirely counter to the economic incentives that animate ad tech companies.
- notriddle 5y agoTristan Harris, the author of this presentation, wound up leaving the company. I guess it didn't work.
- rglullis 5y agoI agree with your overall point, but I believe that this could (and hopefully will) change without any top-down mandate. I think we just need a minority group of people who are unbreakable in their intolerance of ad-funded services, much like RMS and the first FOSS developers were intolerant of running any type of proprietary software. It dawned on me with the whole WhatsApp thing of fucking around with the privacy policy: I didn't mind using it before, but that was the final nail in the coffin. I uninstalled it and I told my friends/family that whoever wanted to reach me could do with Matrix, phone or plain email. I also would gladly help set an account for them on my communick group plan. Of course not all of them did, but the ones who did realized that it was not the end of the world to use a new app and were glad to be able to say that they were not enslaved to whatever Facebook had to offer. Some of these friends even signed up for their own plan, so they could invite more people on their own, etc...
- Layke1123 5y agoSpeak for yourself, but some of us don't have social media.