3 ms·
From what I can tell of the paper, this would only replace the disinfectant stage of a waterworks; you'd still need the coagulation, flocculation, sedimentation
by jcranmer 5y ago
From what I can tell of the paper, this would only replace the disinfectant stage of a waterworks; you'd still need the coagulation, flocculation, sedimentation, and maybe the filtration stages of the treatment plant. I don't know what the breakdowns of the various chemical loads for cost is, although I do know that the sodium hypochlorite for disinfection was by far the most heavily-consumed one. (Although the pH control for coagulation/flocculation was no slouch either, especially when all of the algae were busy having sex in summertime).
> How long would the catalyst last in practice?
That is a very interesting question, and one which immediately came to mind when I read the paper. Which is why I fell over laughing when the paper said something along the lines of "it lasts a long time, we tested it after three runs"--three runs is very far from establishing how long it lasts in an industrial setting.
- kragen 5y ago> you'd still need the coagulation, flocculation, sedimentation, and maybe the filtration stages of the treatment plant. Agreed, although lots of people have access to well or river water that's already pretty good if it weren't for the fecal coliforms in it. > Which is why I fell over laughing when the paper said something along the lines of "it lasts a long time, we tested it after three runs" Yes! It probably doesn't dissolve to any significant extent (though I'd be interested to know what the lower detection limit for their ICP-MS results would have been) but crap might build up on it. Still, it would have to be inorganic, fully oxidized crap that was in solution at the initial filtration stage and then precipitated on the catalyst and withstood continuous 200ppm ROS attack, which narrows down the candidates quite a bit. Maybe some kind of transition metal salt that got further oxidized into insolubility inside the reactor? But it has to be preeetty darn insoluble at the usual dissolved-solids levels, and then you could probably solve that problem with a little bit of carbonate or something upstream from the catalyst.