3 ms·
> ① Potable water needs are 5.7 ℓ/day/person, not 380. > Your figure of 4.4 mℓ/s/person is 380 liters per day per person (100 gallons per day per person), but
by jcranmer 5y ago
> ① Potable water needs are 5.7 ℓ/day/person, not 380.
> Your figure of 4.4 mℓ/s/person is 380 liters per day per person (100 gallons per day per person), but Burning Man recommends 1.5 gallons per day per person (5.7 liters/day/person, 0.066 mℓ/s/person), which includes water for showers, for cooking, and for drinking in a very dry environment with extensive physical exertion, though not for bidets. My experience at Burning Man is that you can get by on less.
So the figure of 100 gallons per day per person is the conversion factor literally built into Virginia's waterworks regulations (e.g., you're class 4 if you treat less than 0.5 MGD of water and you service fewer than 5,000 people). From my experience working at a water treatment plant, 100 gallons per day per person is the right order of magnitude for the amount of water that is actually used.
Yes, most of that water does not need to be potable (97% is the statistic I've heard cited). But if you want to supply both potable and non-potable water, you need to duplicate the entire distribution infrastructure; you can't just treat 3% of the water and say "that's good enough, right?"
- kragen 5y ago> Yes, most of that water does not need to be potable (97% is the statistic I've heard cited). But if you want to supply both potable and non-potable water, you need to duplicate the entire distribution infrastructure; you can't just treat 3% of the water and say "that's good enough, right?" Agreed! To speculate about where the difference between 3% (your figure) and 1.5% (my 65×) comes from; maybe people in Virginia take more showers, take longer showers, and use more water to wash their dishes, than people at Burning Man? If you're disinfecting water at a household, building, or neighborhood level, though, rather than a town or city, duplicating the entire distribution infrastructure is a totally reasonable thing to do. For example, it might amount to running three water pipes instead of two vertically through the building core, next to the 40 chimneys and the elevator shaft, or having a potable-water faucet next to your sink that's hooked up to a water disinfection filter, or keeping a peroxide-generating water jug in the fridge, next to the potatoes, or having a water sanitizer in the utility closet next to the hot-water heater. In this sense, centralization of water treatment is imposing a 30× or 60× waste factor, which is just a staggering factor: literally 97%–99% of its output is wasted! What's even more amazing is that, historically anyway, it makes up for it by improving convenience, safety, and reliability by an even greater factor. Except, I guess, in places like Flint. I still think that, with current technology, an ozone generator or germicidal lamp is probably cheaper than this catalytic ROS generation stuff. But it'll be interesting to see how it develops.