13 ms·
The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020)
- tqi 5y agoReading the article, it's unclear to me what the cost actually is?
- DerpyBaby123 5y agoLet me summarize through quotes: >This is not an update, but a new messaging system from which you can’t switch back. > These are simply features presented to artificially devalue one of the systems, distract from the real changes, and manipulate users into changing to a different system. > this change will eventually link to your real name.
- tqi 5y agoHm well the first two aren't really costs, are they? The third is a conjecture, and as I understand it this is only being offered to people who already have linked their Facebook and Instagram accounts?
- reaperducer 5y agoI'm not sure the third part is conjecture. The EFF has an entire article about it: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/12/changes-facebooks-real-names-policy-still-dont-fix-problem https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/12/changes-facebooks-real...
- tqi 5y agoAh sorry, I was being unclear. Facebook definitely has a "real name" policy, but it isn't clear to me why a unified messaging experience means that your real name will now be shown to other users. That seems like a product decision, rather than an inevitability. As an aside, I don't like this feature and have not opted into it because I actually dislike interoperability. If there was a hypothetical way to get Twitter DM / IG Direct / Messenger / iMessages all in one unified inbox, I would never use it because I actually prefer to keep things in context. My persona and networks on the various platforms are different on purpose, and I like to keep it that way.
- spicybright 5y agoDitto with this. If my reddit account and SMS messages every intermixed, I would be a very very unhappy camper lol
- cartoonworld 5y ago>it isn't clear to me why a unified messaging experience means that your real name will now be shown to other users. That seems like a product decision, rather than an inevitability. They've probably noticed that Instagram has more marketshare with younger audiences and better engagement, where Facebook is full of your grandma and "old people". If they can slowly boil the frog and make them the same, they have a much stronger grip. Its better to ask for forgiveness than for permission.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- croes 5y agoIt costs you your choice.
- DerpyBaby123 5y agoYes, the first is a literal cost, you lose something you used to be able to use. The second is the cost of a degraded system of instagram messaging
- nine_k 5y agoWhen you use a free but not open product, you are not the customer. This is an old and tired idea, but also true. If you want features not disappearing or changing when you don't want them to, you need to be in control. I know only two ways to be in control: you either pay (and the agreement contains a provision about the product properties you care about), or manage it yourself. Using a free-as-in-beer service always puts someone else in control, not you. Bear it in mind every time you register with such a service, and shape your expectations.
- cartoonworld 5y agoYes, proprietary software is negative in the freedom dimension. You have to realize that what your saying here is a category error: The libre alternatives don't have billions of dollars of marketing, engineering, market cap and users. EFF here is trying to point out exactly what you are espousing. These kind of dark patterns are used at all levels to drive engagement, including sign up and retention. ("But ... How will I be able to talk to my friends if I delete Facebook??") I can't recommend a solution, but "Well, its free, what do you expect?" is even worse.
- nine_k 5y agoWould you prefer to hold private parties somehow liable to follow your convenience or best interest, and not their best interest? Anyone who would suggest that should prepare for this approach to be applied to themselves — that is, being coerced to do what some other people want. Whatever it is, it's not freedom. (Yes, indeed, the law works by coercion in the common interests. But I don't see any law having been broken here.) So yes, it's free to play — what did you expect? Too much? Memorize this, and remember next time. Tell your friends and relatives what to not expect. Name and shame the entities which did something unsavory: this helps make users less gullible, and through that, nudges companies to be more careful. Consider avoiding the use of stuff you don't control for important things. Be conscious when consuming free candy from a for-profit entity, even if you think your interests are currently aligned. But don't force anybody's hand.
- catcher 5y agoIt seems like Facebook is trying to prevent anti-trust regulatory action by making it harder to split up / distinguish its core products. Although I’m unsure of how effective that would be.
- mrkramer 5y agoZuck already merged Facebook's and Instagram's database so good luck splitting them. I hope free market economy prevails or in another words lawsuits fail. They should've learnt their lesson with Microsoft(antitrust is waste of taxpayers' money).
- cycomanic 5y agoStandard oil? Antitrust is only a waste of taxpayers' money if there's no real willingness to go after the offenders.
- mrkramer 5y agoWhat happened to Microsoft? Microsoft still controls 70-90% market share of computer operating system industry. Amazon, Google, Facebook and Apple achieved dominant market position through legal and fair market competition.
- throwaway3699 5y agoPeople stopped caring about Windows being dominant years ago. Mac and Linux became competitive for those who wanted it, mobile ate the world, and Windows only dominates in Office and gaming, neither of which are apparently worth fighting over.
- mrkramer 5y ago>Windows only dominates in Office and gaming, neither of which are apparently worth fighting over. Everyone and everything is worth fighting over.
- SheinhardtWigCo 5y agoSame. As a Facebook skeptic and EFF donor, I think this article is unhelpful because it tries to portray user choice as something bad just because Facebook is involved. It totally misses that most software platforms do not allow users to opt-out of massive UI/UX changes and the world could be better if they did. When there are countless legitimate criticisms to make regarding Facebook, an institution as influential as EFF coming out with something this weak actually hurts the cause.
- JustVestedSeeYa 5y agoHere’s a choice … don’t use it.
- desine 5y agoI was a fan of social media at it's birth. Like many, I saw an ability to stay in touch with old acquaintances with less effort and intrusion. We didn't have to interrupt each other with a phone call, or worry about replying to a text in a reasonable amount of time. People would post updates, interact with the updates, and thus in a sense interact with each other's personalities manifested in these posts/comments/likes. It was convenient, and I feel, beneficial. Then came "the algorithms", capitalist refinement of the experience to increase user attention and interaction. Or more accurately, addiction. This is where I had to quit, a couple years ago. The updated algorithms (instead of linear time representation of posts) did cause me to care too much. There was too frequently new content to see, from things I didn't even care about. Cool videos from GoPro, RedBull, etc. Weeks old updates from forgotten friends sprinkled in to make it personal. Much of the time I used to spend in my head, in a good way, such as in line at a grocery store, or waiting for a project to compile, I was now refreshing feeds. My mind operated more in the realm of social media than in it's own existence. Now we get to the consolidation. All of your social media, even your "private" chats on WhatsApp, tied to one profile. One centralized database of your life, quickly queryable, cleaned, sorted, and available to advertisers and governments alike. One part of me actually likes this change from Facebook. At least they're being honest about their data being merged. But it's another optimization designed to generate revenue, do not believe otherwise. It's one more step towards the apex of profitability. I don't know what the results of this step will be, but I'll probably be bitter about it, and make another rambling comment in a couple of years.
- annadane 5y agoThis is a perfectly legitimate comment, but I would go one step further: throw Mark Zuckerberg in jail. While it may seem to be an industry wide practice I believe that he is above and beyond the most predatory and cynical of the practitioners of these things. Remember how Facebook lied to advertisers about video metrics for 2 years? Other companies will look at fb's success and say 'hey, I have to do that too'. Not realizing the only way they're successful is because they have a wanton disregard for any decency whatsoever
- minikites 5y agoIt's abundantly clear that markets aren't self-regulating. We need government regulation to counteract harmful actions of businesses.
- sodality2 5y agoNot self regulating in a way that benefits the average user, sure. It is absolutely self regulating in a way that benefits corporations.
- strogonoff 5y agoImagine a parallel universe where social network’s interests and the interests of its users were actually aligned—all because paid social was seen as the norm from get go. Fully featured APIs? Multi-platform third-party messaging clients? Ethical privacy policies? Once the end user is able to vote with their money, so many possibilities suddenly open. The status quo is much more preferable to social networks and their shareholders, of course. Charging advertisers arbitrary amounts based on eyeball count no one can actually verify, while not having to worry about losing paying customers due to ignoring requests of locked-in users, is a nice position to be in. To the point about market regulation, IMO there may be a place for a limited, surgically precise yet not targeting any specific companies intervention (for example, “you are obligated to provide an API covering the entirety of your GUI features if you serve more than N users”) that would, a few causal links down the line, break such shockingly dysfunctional customer-provider relationships, normalize paid social and let the market do its thing.
- zo1 5y agoIf you peel back the layers and sequence of causation, I think you'll always find that there is some government intervention that has a hand in these "market" failures. Unfortunately, I don't think capitalism can function properly in an environment that has government fiddling, which is what we're seeing. And I say that as a full free-market advocate. Either way, government is too blame. Both for not regulating these bad things away, and also for having some hand in causing them N-levels back (you just can't see or prove this one easily). It's a nice sweet spot for governments and their officials and advocates, because they can always absolve themselves by blaming the free-market in one way or another. They do too much or do the wrong regulation, causing something "bad" in the market, and boom they blame "the market". Likewise, they put some half-assed regulations that don't do much and yet again they blame "not enough regulation". The entire thing is ridiculously circular and self-reinforcing. Almost as if it's been designed for argumentative deadlock.
- olah_1 5y agoI wonder if a solution is a "login with facebook/instagram" option on messengers like Matrix / Element. So it could be as frictionless as possible to get people on it and then everyone has a matrix ID as well.
- sneak 5y agoNo, because you can't disable Facebook Messenger if you have a Facebook account, and people will still message you there. The Facebook accounts must be deleted as part of any solution.
- ASalazarMX 5y agoI guess it's google accounts then. No one uses their messengers because they keep changing names.
- swiley 5y agoAlternatively set your status to "email me" and just never go to facebook again. That worked for me but that was 5 years ago.
- kevincox 5y agoIt would be nice to set up these Silos in Matrix identity servers so that you can find your friends. This currently works with email and phone but adding facebook, instagram, snapshat, twitter... would be a nice step forward.
- AnonHP 5y agoMods: This one needs 2020 in the title since the linked post is from November 2020. I’m not sure what actions anyone reading this can take now. They may have already succumbed to the relentless prompts and accepted the new messenger.
- avalys 5y agoIf you don’t like it, you don’t have to use Instagram and you don’t have to use Facebook. These are completely non-essential services in every way.
- tristanc 5y agoI feel like this comes up again and again. For some people Instagram or Facebook are sometimes the only way to communicate with new peers without introducing too much friction. In France, for example, most of my friends will exclusively use Instagram when connecting with new people.
- milkytron 5y agoAre there no other options? Do your friends use them exclusively because they are sticky? Is there actually a feature that makes them unable to use other apps? I find a lot of times, people just don't want to change, regardless of whether they should. I was the first to delete my Facebook in my group of friends, and now they all have, and my family has mostly jumped ship as well. I'm sure your friends can use something else, they just choose not to.
- croes 5y agoSome companies and governments only communicate through social media.
- wsinks 5y agoRight, they choose not to invest more time and thought into something else. That's why the pattern of the social media bait and switch is frustrating. The company made a promise. People bought that promise. Company changes the promise and puts a bow on it and dresses it up. Company only notes the promise in the fine print. But because it already has the power and because people don't want to be on alert 100% of the time (because that can actually kill you), the deception works. So you bring up a fallacy. The actual option here is "pay attention to every company you use to communicate all the time" or don't pay attention and accidentally agree to something not well advertised. Interesting fact, Facebook has an F rating on the BBB's website. Of course, the very first complaint on there is an interesting one that completely misconstrues the first amendment right, but again, that's just interesting. (https://www.bbb.org/us/ca/menlo-park/profile/social-media-marketing/facebook-1116-385674/customer-reviews https://www.bbb.org/us/ca/menlo-park/profile/social-media-ma...)
- theo-born 5y agoThe terms and conditions should state: I will provide you with all of my personal data for you to sell it. Check here _ I will be spammed with ads for useless shit that I don't need. Check here _ I will not sue you for performing any unethical or illicit practices Check here _
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- strulovich 5y ago> I will be spammed with ads for useless shit that I don't need. Check here _ Isn’t this the exact opposite though? Your data being used for targeting will minimize bad ads that you see. (Facebook employee, never worked on ads or anything similar though)
- Nicksil 5y ago>Isn’t this the exact opposite though? Your data being used for targeting will minimize bad ads that you see. Perhaps if it did what it says on the tin, but it usually doesn't, so no. >(Facebook employee, never worked on ads or anything similar though) Facebook is ads.
- suprfsat 5y agoIt is possible for Facebook to simultaneously vacuum up large amounts of personal data and still serve trash advertisements.
- neolog 5y agoNot only possible, it's actually required by Facebook's business model. The set of things that people actually need to buy isn't large enough to support Facebook's scale.
- judge2020 5y ago> Facebook is ads. OP gets paid via ads, but does not work on the actual ad team and thus wouldn't know any actual inner workings of the targeting systems.
- swiley 5y agoThe best thing you can do, not just for yourself but for those around you: Say no to smartphone apps.
- munk-a 5y agoI said no to a smartphone entirely and it's been working out pretty well for me except that dumbphones are becoming such a specialty device that the quality has been dropping while prices have been steadily increasing.
- swiley 5y agoSaying no to smartphones is certainly impressive but IMO you don't have to go that far, just say no to apps and web services that act like apps.
- croes 5y ago>Facebook made promises to keep the two services operating separately, and Facebook broke those promises just two years later, with similarly unclear notice to users When will we learn? These are businesses. A promise is worthless, the only thing that matters are contracts.
- wnevets 5y ago> the only thing that matters are contracts. even those don't matter. The only thing that actually matters are the consequences.
- croes 5y agoIf they break a contract you can sue, that leads to consequences.
- danuker 5y agoExcept the contract says "we may need to update these Terms from time to time to accurately reflect our services and practices.". Do you have the same liberty to change the terms? No. You are free to stop using the service.
- hansel_der 5y agonot all consequences are equal thou
- colpabar 5y agoWhen every EULA in existence contains a "despite everything we just said, we can actually just do whatever we want if we decide we want to" clause, why would you expect a contract to be binding in any meaningful way? Companies this big simply won't enter contracts that could potentially cause real damage if broken. And good look suing a company with billions of dollars. Even with a strong case and good lawyers, they will drag out the process and all the court costs will make it impossible to finish, unless you also have billions of dollars.
- wnevets 5y ago
- annadane 5y agoYet another lie from Mark Zuckerberg. "No, we won't merge <company we just bought>. Promise." He's not trustworthy at all, he's such a slimeball
- ducttapecrown 5y agoI really like the new Instagram and Facebook messengers because of how rich they are: you can send text, audio, pictures and video, and links get nice previews. You can control how long your messages stay around, and you can react to messages with the full emoji set.
- jwmoz 5y agoHi Mark
- mercer 5y agoI did not hit her, I did nooooot
- hi5eyes 5y agojust for everyone to keep in mind wrt to link previews on fb owned products https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/10/study-shows-which-messengers-leak-your-data-drain-your-battery-and-more/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/10/study... > Instagram owner Facebook said in an email that its servers download only a downscaled version of an image, not the original file, and that the company doesn't store that data. The email also said that its servers run the JavaScript to vet it for security. Mysk, however, said that the video demonstrates that Instagram downloaded a 2.6GB file (an Ubuntu ISO with the file renamed to ubuntu.png) in its entirety. He also noted that most other messengers strip out JavaScript rather than downloading it and running it on their servers. https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/link-preview-comparison.jpg https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/link-...
- naturalauction 5y ago>you can send text, audio, pictures and video, and links get nice previews. Not pdfs or other files though! >you can react to messages with the full emoji set. Only on mobile for me
- Ashanmaril 5y agoThis article doesn't even mention how horrible the implementation is, too. It didn't merge your conversations with a person into a single thread across Facebook Messenger and Instagram. Instead it created 4 permutations of threads with a person. * Your Messenger + Friend's Messenger * Your Instagram + Friend's Instagram * Your Messenger + Friend's Instagram * Your Instagram + Friend's Messenger Each of these conversations will result in a new, separate thread, even if your Facebook and Instagram accounts are linked. It's such a mess.
- yellow_lead 5y agoIndeed. I'm not sure why anyone thought this was a good idea. Or why they didn't listen to programmers/architects telling them it surely wasn't. Successfully untangling this could result in some promotions once they realize the idiocy of this.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- code_duck 5y agoSometimes I feel like Facebook shuffles things around just to make work for themselves.
- wholinator2 5y agoWell I mean, if you think about, everything they do is just making up work. They've basically succeeded in the whole "mega corporation too big to fail, huge amounts of regular automated revenue" thing. They could probably kick their feet up and just coast for a while and not worry but instead they have thousands of employees and hundreds of managers all making up things to do to try and position themselves to make more money in the future. They're already just making up stuff to do
- Schiendelman 5y agoMaybe the architects are relying on untangling to get promoted in the future?
- throwawayboise 5y ago> Tech companies like Facebook have mastered the art of distorting choice and consent. I have seen this spill over into all sorts of everyday things. HR policy changes at work are communicated more like this now. You suddenly get an interstitial when logging in one day, demanding that you accept or acknowledge some change or new policy. There is often no other option, no avenues given to protest or question or even discuss it. These things used to be communicated by email, before that by memo, making it apparent who the author was and thus who to follow up to if you felt the need to do so. Now it's an annonymous "we" who have decided that this is the new order of things, and if I want to get on with doing my work I need to acquiesce.
- deregulateMed 5y agoAt least it's easy to switch jobs. Social media has the network effect so it's less easy. Although tell that to mid level managers and they don't quite think it's easy to change jobs.
- koolba 5y agoIt’s much easier to quit all social media than it is for most people to quit their job and find a new one.
- bingidingi 5y agoRight but if you quit a job you're not quitting all jobs. That's not true with social media outside of fringe options like Mastodon (Which is like quitting a FAANG job to work at Wendy's... and this is coming from someone that likes Mastodon)
- yellow_lead 5y agoI wonder what the long term plan is with this. Instagram and Facebook become one app? Surely they see that's not a good idea. Personally, I think Facebook as a product is struggling heavily and instead of letting it die, they're going to take down their other apps with them. I won't complain if they want to destroy themselves though.
- toomanybeersies 5y ago> Personally, I think Facebook as a product is struggling heavily Maybe in the USA, but Facebook is seeing massive growth in Southeast Asia, particularly in Indonesia and the Philippines.
- josteink 5y ago> Facebook called it a step toward “interoperability, saying, “We want to give people a choice so they can reach their friends across these networks from whichever app they prefer.” If they really mean that (and ofcourse they don’t), they should help drive a new, open protocol, not create a new closed, centralized platform.
- purpmint008 5y agoAnti-trust regulators should pounce on Facebook if they try to merge WhatsApp and Facebook in a serious way.