5 ms·
That type of behavior is a consequence of war. It happens, and the victors define who is worthy of punishment or praise. Using World War 2 as an example, the A
by Spooky23 5y ago
That type of behavior is a consequence of war. It happens, and the victors define who is worthy of punishment or praise.
Using World War 2 as an example, the Army Air Forces immolated Japanese cities with white phosphorus and napalm before the atomic bomb was available. In Tokyo alone, hundreds of thousands of people were reduced to ash, and the glow of the firestorm was visible from hundreds of miles away. Those actions, followed by the atomic bombing, are marginally controversial today but largely accepted as “ok”.
Because the allies won, those actions are rationalized, and those rationalizations have merit. Had Japan won, events like the rape of Nanking would have been rationalized by their standards, and actions of the US Army Air Forces would have been viewed very differently.
With respect to Haiti, the colonialist mindset focuses on the individual tragedy of slaughtered Europeans living their life in the colony. But from the perspective of the rebel slaves, those individuals were complicit in systematic barbarous conditions in the cane fields that killed thousands of slaves horribly, every month for a century or more. The wife of the banker who financed or leased slaves is the same as the overseer. Those rebels won the battle, but ultimately did not win the war nor write the history.
- soperj 5y agoNo one really accepts them as ok except the country that did them.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoActs of war, like military bombings during a conflict, are obviously not on the same level as genocide. There's a very crucial difference and I invite readers to look up what 'genocide' means. This is an off-topic diversion in this discussion, though. I think it's important to call things out and to see history for the complex mess it is instead of trying to divide everything and everyone between heroes beyond reproach and unredeemable villains. Yes, the black slaves were treated barbarously, and yes they committed genocide against the white population after they gained their freedom. That's what happened. We can look for explanations but I think we should avoid trying to look for excuses because once we start to label some genocides less wrong than others, or even acceptable to the point of defending them then we've crossed a major red line. Shockingly it looks like that red line has been crossed in this thread.
- the_af 5y ago> Acts of war, like military bombings, are obviously not on the same level as genocide. There's a very crucial difference. What's the difference when the target is the civilian population, as was the case with the bombings of Japan (and many of the cities in the European theatre of the war as well)? Other than the fact bombing cities from a B-29 flying high is more impersonal for the perpetrators.
- greedo 5y agoActually, when conducting the firebomb missions, the B-29s flew at low level. Their after action reports clearly mentioned the smell of smoke etc. It was far from impersonal. " In January 1945, General Curtis LeMay arrived in the Mariana Islands to take over the problem-plagued B-29 command. For two months, his crews flew similar high-altitude missions over Japan with little more success. His job on the line, General LeMay decided on a risky new strategy: his pilots would fly daring, dangerous bombing missions at altitudes as low as 5,000 feet, low enough to be within range of anti-aircraft weapons. Robert Rodenhouse was shocked: "We thought they could throw the kitchen sink up there and hit us. Can you imagine flying a big four-engine bomber at 5,000 feet? Why that was just unheard of, absolutely unheard of. And like my crew says, I think those generals lost their marbles. They weren't thinking straight." The low-altitude bombing runs turned out to be highly successful. The planes carried much larger bomb loads. Crews flew at night to avoid enemy fighters. And flight personnel were kept to a minimum. Most of the gunners were removed to make room for still more bombs -- incendiary bombs." https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/pacific-b-29s/ https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/pacific...
- creddit 5y agoGenerally very different standards are applied when speaking about actions during a war against belligerents and those actions taken after a war against a subjugated people.
- crashdelta 5y ago"Using World War 2 as an example, the Army Air Forces immolated Japanese cities with white phosphorus and napalm before the atomic bomb was available. In Tokyo alone, hundreds of thousands of people were reduced to ash, and the glow of the firestorm was visible from hundreds of miles away. Those actions, followed by the atomic bombing, are marginally controversial today but largely accepted as 'ok'." How else would you deal with an enemy that would not give in? Most people fail to understand that the axis was all in, in every way, shape and form. When it comes to the Japanese, they flat out were not going to give up. Their will had to be broken, somehow, someway.
- didroe 5y agohttps://www.thenation.com/article/world/why-the-us-really-bombed-hiroshima/ https://www.thenation.com/article/world/why-the-us-really-bo... > “the vast destruction wreaked by the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki and the loss of 135,000 people made little impact on the Japanese military.” - Plaque hanging in the National Museum of the US Navy > In its one paragraph, it makes clear that Truman’s political advisers overruled the military in determining how the end of the war with Japan would be approached. > "the use of this barbarous weapon at Hiroshima and Nagasaki was of no material assistance in our war against Japan" - Truman's chief of staff > “the Japanese position was hopeless even before the first atomic bomb fell, because the Japanese had lost control of their own air.” - Commanding general of the US Army Air Forces > “[Byrnes] was concerned about Russia’s postwar behavior…[and thought] that Russia might be more manageable if impressed by American military might, and that a demonstration of the bomb might impress Russia.” - Manhattan Project scientist Leo Szilard, talking about Secretary of State James Byrnes It doesn't seem like dropping the bombs served any military purpose.
- nickik 5y ago> made little impact on the Japanese military The military capability being broken was not the goal, and it also not what decided the war. > made little impact on the Japanese military That would matter if the goal of the bomb or impact had been about 'material' but it wasn't, and its not how the war was decided. > the Japanese position was hopeless even before the first atomic bomb fell, because the Japanese had lost control of their own air Again, that doesn't matter. Their position was hopeless literally the second they started the war. They literally started the war knowing they couldn't win. The bomb was not there for military impact as militarily japan had already been beaten along every possible measure of such things. Japan was surrounded, had no food import its navy and air force were done. > It doesn't seem like dropping the bombs served any military purpose. The military purpose was ending the war. And in fact it did exactly that. You can actually go read about the highest level of Japan decision making. This is well researched now. Not a single member of the high highest decision council was for ending the war or even negotiation. Literally nobody. Despite starvation, fire bombings and military defeat. After first bomb fell the they were starting to have meeting where they discussed the situation and the waste majority of them still were absolutely against ending the war. After the second bomb the mood shifted, multiple members changed there position and with support from the emperor managed to overrule the still considerable opposition to peace from many of the military leaders. The idea that this would have been possible without the bomb is simply not historical. Some people claim the Soviet invasion was the deciding factor, but just like losing territory to the East and South, losing territory in the West would not have changed them. Here are the alternative options: - Surround Japan for extended period of time - Full invasion of Japan The first option would have been essentially a 10+ year genocide of much of Japans population and transforming it back into an agricultural society. The government would simply not have given up, they knew about the starvation that would happen in Japan and they were perfectly willing to endure that. The second would have cost the US 10s to 100s of men, and the Japanese likely 10x as much. There were 1000s of civilians suicides even in some of the outer islands, and 10-100s of soldiers who essentially committed suicide by attack. What do you think would happen when a US army went from village to village, city by city threw Japan following a retreating Japanese army and government north right across all of Japan. The Japanese army was willing to turn every city int Stalingrad. Endless bonsi charges where US soldiers would have to basically mass execute 1000s of Japanese soldiers who had run out of ammo. So what would your solution have been?
- redis_mlc 5y agoYour comment is silly. In the European theater, Germany did firebomb areas of Britain, so it wasn't just Allied behavior. And Japan not only started war with the US, they were literally anti-Geneva Convention - they passed a law to execute American captured airmen.
- the_af 5y agoAre you sure you understand the argument the OP was making? They didn't claim only the Allies engaged in this behavior, nor that Japan was blameless. Their claim was in the first sentence, and let me quote it verbatim: > "That type of behavior is a consequence of war. It happens, and the victors define who is worthy of punishment or praise." And it goes on to elaborate: > "Because the allies won, those actions are rationalized, and those rationalizations have merit. Had Japan won, events like the rape of Nanking would have been rationalized by their standards, and actions of the US Army Air Forces would have been viewed very differently." To spell it out, the argument is that it's silly to single out the Haitians when they murdered their oppressors (and people in the same social caste as their oppressors), because this kind of stuff tends to happen in war regardless of who the involved parties are. Western powers engage in it in their own wars and conflicts, it's just that since they are usually considered the victors, this behavior is less often singled out as barbarous (it is, but less often). Conversely, nobody identifies the former Haitian slaves as part of a victorious West -- especially since Haiti is a failed state and decidedly not part of "us" -- and therefore it's easier to single them out as barbarous and genocidal. Things not claimed in the other post: - That Japan wasn't guilty of similar crimes. - That it was just Allied behavior. - That the US was worse than Japan or viceversa.
- redis_mlc 5y agoWhoosh. It was claimed that somehow firebombing Japan was immoral, when it was the logical outcome of Japan starting the war.
- andrepd 5y agoVery well put
- dang 5y agoPlease don't take HN threads further into flamewar hell. It's exactly what we don't want here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html