8 ms·
U.S. to add ‘X’ gender marker on passports
- chaorace 5y agoCool, though I wonder how long this convention will stick, granted that this is a policy by executive fiat -- It would suck for a lot of people if they suddenly had to redo their passports 4/8/12 years down the road. Is this an international first, by the way? If so, I wonder if other countries will adopt this "X" designation
- tomlockwood 5y agoAustralia has X as an option for passports. I think some other countries do too, but not sure.
- _trampeltier 5y agoA few countrys have X already. Some countrys talk about it.
- mypastself 5y agoTo be honest, I’m not sure what the purpose of having such information in a passport is in the first place.
- kayodelycaon 5y agoBecause sex is(/was?) considered an identifying feature, in the same way eye color, skin color, height, weight, and other physical characteristics are identifying. Now, should it be on there? Maybe? But if it must be, having an opt-out option is important, because people may not look male or female, rendering making identification less accurate. That's before we get into gender, where forcing someone to pick male or female when they may be neither is rather dehumanizing.
- Hamuko 5y ago>Because sex is(/was?) considered an identifying feature, in the same way eye color, skin color, height, weight, and other physical characteristics are identifying. Do American passports have all those things?
- tzs 5y agoThe application asks for height, hair color, and eye color. I don't see any of those printed on mine in any obvious way. There are no fields for them like there is for sex. They could be in the electronic information, though, or encoded in the long string of digits at the bottom of the passport.
- tablespoon 5y ago> Do American passports have all those things? Some do. My driver's license is a also a passport card and has all of those except skin color.
- Muromec 5y agoBecause passports were invited when women were not necessarily able to travel alone. Also even today US government discriminates against women when issuing visas in certain countries.
- yokaze 5y agoThe X comes from a pre-existing standard from the ICAO, which gives the options F,M,X. X standing for unspecified.
- bloak 5y agoThe ICAO standard says a passport must have a field labelled "sex" containing F, M or X; in this context, X means "unknown" or "unspecified". About a dozen countries will issue passports with an X in the "sex" field, but I'm not sure which of them, if any, will do it for anyone who asks for it, which seems to be what's proposed for the US. The really radical thing to do would be to only issue passports with an X in the "sex" field. That way non-binary people wouldn't be treated any differently.
- deregulateMed 5y agoPolitically this is good and I'm pro trans/LGBT+ rights. Scientifically I want to ask, is there gender fluidity? I spent a few hours last weekend reading scientific papers on this topic because someone here posted confidently Male and Female don't depend on organs. I came to the conclusion that there are differences in the brain, but outside that difference, males are males. The differences in the brain could be described as a mental illness or if you prefer, something else brain related. So my questions, does anyone have a scientific paper that can prove gender fluidity in mammals?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Simulacra 5y agoThere are only two genders in science. Politically, they are infinite.
- tablespoon 5y agoReplying to the GP here, because his comment is flagged/dead now. > Scientifically I want to ask, is there gender fluidity? I spent a few hours last weekend reading scientific papers on this topic because someone here posted confidently Male and Female don't depend on organs. Honestly, the terminology in that space is a mess. For awhile I think people were drawing a distinction between "gender" and "sex," where "gender" was more ideological (man/woman) and sex biological (male/female), but it sounds like the person you were talking about was conflating those things (which may or may not have been intentional). But frankly, I don't think "is there gender fluidity" is a scientific question. It's an ideological/cultural question, even if you have scientific authorities using their authority to shape the discussion.
- wpietri 5y agoYeah, same. Here's my reply to that poster: If you're going to be scientific about this (which a lot of people have if you want to read their work) you have to start with the biological and observational data and build up from there. Otherwise, you're just taking social categories learned in childhood and trying to fit data to them. Statements like "males are males" are basically the "Pluto is a planet" of gender. It's not scientific conclusion, it's asserting a belief.
- pelagicAustral 5y agoSoon enough it will not be enough, then other groups will want Z, K, L, Ñ and whatnot... maybe even an emoji
- mxmilkiib 5y agoHoping for a progressive result in the UK supreme court next week. https://elancane.livejournal.com https://elancane.livejournal.com
- mxmilkiib 5y agoHot dang, flagged by users.
- wpietri 5y agoFab. This always struck me as archaic and unnecessary for things like passports (and driver's licenses). Maybe it made sense before photos and biometrics. But these days it adds nothing to a border guard's ability to decide if they have the right document for the person in front of them.
- brighton36 5y agoIt didn't strike you as archaic. That's a lie. Its appealing to you. And you know full well that a border guard finds utility here. This is a comment in bad faith.
- koolba 5y ago> But these days it adds nothing to a border guard's ability to decide if they have the right document for the person in front of them. If the border officials are willing to perform a strip search, it cuts the number of people that could use a given fake ID roughly in half.
- wpietri 5y agoIt really doesn't. If they have looked at the photo and decided it's a match, that already contains a lot of information on gender and sex a guard will use. If a guard decides there's a mismatch, we're well out into the extremes of the probability distributions. When we compare that to the chance the ID is a good enough fake to pass otherwise but bad enough that it doesn't have the gender right and the chance that it's just bureaucratic error, a mandatory genital inspection makes very little sense. And that's before we get to the practical costs of making border guards into dick inspectors. We could hypothetically get to your 50% number by just inspecting everybody's genitals, I guess. Except the false positive rate from turning security guards into medical experts would be through the roof.
- yummypaint 5y agoA few months ago I showed up for a flight and found out my ticket was accidentally booked with the wrong gender when I put my id in the scanner at security. The solution was to dash back down to the airline counter, have the attendant scribble something on the boarding pass, then run back to security who let me through. No further verifications or anything, just a waste of 3 peoples time. Specifying gender serves no security or verification purpose whatsoever. Why are airlines even asking for this info?
- Simulacra 5y agoTotally unnecessary and I think will lead to confusion and fraud.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gilbetron 5y agoI've thought "X" would make a not-terrible gender neutral pronoun for English, or at least not as terrible as other ones. As an engineer, X is a good generic variable anyway, and "Bob went to the store and x bought some beer and pretzels" reads ok. Maybe this passport thing will make that a reality. Although it depends if X on the passport means trans/intersex or if it means "prefer not to say".
- dariusj18 5y agoI agree, though I think it should be xe and we can bring in the Chinese style X phoneme for it's pronunciation.
- jfengel 5y agoSingular "they" has such an established place that it's rapidly becoming the de facto answer. Perhaps not optimal, but if you can find anything about English that's optimal, I want it caught and shot immediately. In this case "they" has priority. We've been using it as a singular pronoun for longer than people have used X as a variable. Chaucer used singular "they" in the 14th century; X as a variable is generally credited to Descartes in the 16th.
- 5y ago
- deregulateMed 5y agoYikes I asked a science based question and got flagged for it. And I'm pro LGBT+. HN being curated.
- kube-system 5y agoYour question reads as disingenuous. In the case that you aren't: Sex can be determined biologically. Gender has a significant social component, and can't be determined through biology. For example: "Why is lipstick in the women's department at the store?" is not a question that can be answered through biology. However, if you want examples of non-binary sex, that exists too: it's called intersex.
- rm8x 5y agoIntersex people are male or female. Male/female comes down to gametes and intersex does not somehow prove that biological sex is a spectrum.
- brandmeyer 5y ago"rare" doesn't mean "never". Caster Semenya is an Olympic candidate who is getting disqualified from some women's racing events because she is intersex and has just a little bit too much biological masculinity to compete as a woman.
- pseudalopex 5y agoSome people don't produce gametes.
- bloak 5y agoSee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex I don't think anyone's claiming that "biological sex is a spectrum", but some people "do not fit the typical definitions for male or female bodies". Some are born with ambiguous external genitalia, but there are also people who look completely female while having male (XY) chromosomes. Since various distinct medical conditions are involved, it doesn't make sense to call it a "spectrum" even from a medical point of view.
- klodolph 5y agoThere’s a percentage of children born every year considered “intersex”. The percentage will vary depending on what your criteria for “intersex” is. In the past, the doctor would just pick a gender, and then (in the case of ambiguous genitalia) perform surgery on the child to make their genitalia conform to the norms for the gender that the doctor chose. This is a bit of a crapshoot, since you don’t know if you made the right choice for that child. This is the demarcation problem rearing its ugly head again. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demarcation_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demarcation_problem If you decide that all people are either male or female, you are going to end up arguing about where to draw the line. This is not particle physics, gender does not take “integer values” like the spin of a boson. So we add “X” to the passport to acknowledge the fact that, as much as some people may wish for gender to be a simple binary, reality sometimes defies simple categorization.
- aikah 5y ago> There’s a percentage of children born every year considered “intersex”. The percentage will vary depending on what your criteria for “intersex” is. "intersex" isn't a precondition to put X on a passport, so it's irrelevant. If gender is irrelevant, then remove it from the passport all together.
- klodolph 5y ago> "intersex" isn't a precondition to put X on a passport, so it's irrelevant. I think you may be reading something I didn’t write. I’m certainly neither saying nor implying that being born intersex is or should be a necessary condition for having “X” on your passport.
- wpietri 5y agoI am entirely for removing it altogether, but change rarely happens all at once. "X" seems like a good start.
- pseudalopex 5y agoThe sex field is an ICAO requirement. No country can remove it unilaterally. They can do this.
- filleduchaos 5y agoThis might be a bit of a strange take, but hear me out: this is good and should be the norm regardless of what you think or believe about trans people and/or gender being binary or not. Gender as a social institution is a separate thing to me from gender as a facet of identity. By "social institution" I mean its involvement outside of interpersonal relationships, e.g. in situations like this where it's become the business of the state (and thus information that anybody even glancing at your ID card is privy to). That's patently absurd to me. How is it normal for a complete stranger to look at my ID and know (or at least think they know) what genitals I have? Or casually ask for that on forms? That certainly seems like information that I should have a measure of control over. For a few years now I've been of the opinion that a person should have to opt in to disclose their gender/sex except where actually necessary (e.g. in medical contexts). "Prefer not to disclose" (e.g. X along with M/F) should be a valid answer to anyone else that asks including the government.
- RhysU 5y ago> How is it normal for a complete stranger to look at my ID and know (or at least think they know) what genitals I have? Ignore naughty bits entirely! Everyone fixates on the naughty bits. Sheesh. Imagine a 5'6" male. Imagine a 5'6" female. Imagine them wearing the same outfit. Do they look, stereotypically, different enough that you could tell which one is standing in front of you with high accuracy? Do you think this outward difference might be a useful identification tool to assess if a passport belongs to the passport holder? Must this indicator be sinister? Is it so sinister that the government should reject it for other, possibly more sinister indicators?
- dariusj18 5y ago> Do you think this might be a useful identification tool to assess if a passport belongs to the passport holder? You mean rather than use the picture?
- RhysU 5y agoYou mean the one that can be years and years and years old? That likely was taken at Walgreens some Saturday morning? And which is not verified during the passport renewal? That one?