5 ms·
The report defines it as >In this context, we use the term ‘surveillance-based advertising’ as a blanket >term for digital advertising that is targeted at ind
by charcircuit 5y ago
The report defines it as
>In this context, we use the term ‘surveillance-based advertising’ as a blanket
>term for digital advertising that is targeted at individuals or consumer
>segments, usually through tracking and profiling based on personal data.
This is ridiculous. If I am trying to advertise an Elixer IDE, then I don't want my advertisements shown to any random person on the internet. The majority of users on the internet are not even developers. I want to be able to advertise to a consumer segment which consists of people who are interested in Elixir. "Surveillance" is essential to internet advertising.
- indigochill 5y ago> If I am trying to advertise an Elixer IDE, then I don't want my advertisements shown to any random person on the internet. The definition in the report is poor. Yes, you always need to advertise to a segment. No, you don't have to spy on users to do it. How? Make a website about something and select advertisements that are relevant to the sort of people who are probably interested in the topic of the website. ReadTheDocs has already spun off an ad business that advertises tech stuff to readers of ReadTheDocs because it's reasonable to assume that is the audience that is perusing ReadTheDocs pages.
- charcircuit 5y ago>No, you don't have to spy on users to do it. Assuming you are running an ad network you kind of have to in order to prevent ad fraud. Also by reducing that data you know about someone's interests is the knowledge that they have visited a site at least you will not be able to pick as good of an ad compared to if you had more data.
- danbruc 5y agoThat is the problem of the ad network. If they have to deal with fraud then find a way to solve this but not at the cost of everyone.
- charcircuit 5y agoThe problem with abuse is not special to ad networks. All sites (once they reach a certain size) have to deal with it. Surveillance is needed to handle abuse of your service.
- danbruc 5y agoSurveillance is needed to handle abuse of your service. Provide one example that can not be solved without surveillance.
- charcircuit 5y agoLet's say you run a website with a sign on page. In order to log in a user typically you will run the password through an algorithm like argon2. Verifying a password for an account consumes CPU resources. A malicious may decide to DOS your site by just spamming this endpoint with bogus password to make you waste your time. An easy fix with surveillance is to rate limit people based off their IP address. Without surveillance though there is not much you can do. Scale up your infrastructure to try and out scale the attack? Implement a global rate limit that locks regular users from being able to sign in?
- danbruc 5y agoIs is not surveillance - at the very least not in the relevant sense - if you maintain a temporary list of IPs you have seen in the past minute or hour. This is your best argument why we have to track and profile every human on the planet around the clock?
- charcircuit 5y ago>if you maintain a temporary list of IPs you have seen in the past minute or hour. This is totally surveillance. Just because we delete data after a while, it doesn't mean I didn't surveil you, nor does it mean I haven't used that data I got from you for my own benefit. >This is your best argument why we have to track and profile every human on the planet around the clock? You just asked for an example. If you are suggesting that my argument is to prevent abuse of systems I would say that it justifies tracking every person on the planet.
- indigochill 5y agoWhat's the fraud scenario? Page owners presenting fraudulent visitor/click-through numbers to advertisers? In that scenario, it seems like advertisers would pick up on that pretty quickly when they realize the conversion rate on that supposed traffic is terrible and doesn't warrant the inflated price. In the case they're using an ad network, the network could ban the page owner from their network if they see this pattern from them. Since page owners are materially benefiting from the network, proof of identity should be (probably is? I don't work in the space) applied between the page owner and network to prevent repeat fraud via identity laundering. > you will not be able to pick as good of an ad compared to if you had more data. In theory I lean towards agreeing. I was arguing for tech-powered hyper-personalized ads back when I was studying advertising 2008-2012 (and did a bit of "stealth marketing" in that period where I built relationships with bloggers to share our product before the term "influencer" had hit the mainstream vocabulary). In practice, advertisers do not personalize ads. Facebook has become pretty good about selecting ads that map to my interests thanks to the reach of their spy network, but the ads themselves still aren't personalized at all (they take my interests into account, but not my spending history to realize that I don't have the budget for what they're trying to sell me) and my conversion to a sale because of them is still very, very low.
- stevesearer 5y agoWe sell and host our own advertising which is content-based (office furniture ads on office design content) and think it is a good solution. Instead of selling space by impressions or clicks, we use length of time (monthly) and find it to be a good way to prevent ourselves from trying to game impressions with clickbait or clicks with fake users.
- michaelt 5y ago> What's the fraud scenario? 1. Page owner / Ad network / Ad space auction market middleman fakes clicks to get click revenue 2. Page owner's rival fakes clicks to devalue ad spots 3. Advertiser's agency fakes clicks to make numbers go up 4. Advertiser's rivals fake clicks, to waste advertiser's budget 5. Ad networks 'accidentally' classifying legitimate clicks as fraud, to reduce payouts to page owners.
- Nextgrid 5y agoSell ads based on time periods. "Your ad displayed here for 1 week for this much $$$". Then the only thing that matters is the ROI and it doesn't matter how many bots have clicked on it.
- charcircuit 5y agoThis approach sounds much harder for an ad network to pull off and sounds like it would add a lot of risk and complication. For example, what if a web master decides they don't want to have ads on their site anymore. Whoever just paid for that space gets screwed.
- Nextgrid 5y agoThis can all be sorted by contracts? The ad network pays out only after the ad has fully ran for 7 days, and if the webmaster removes the ad or similar they don't get paid and the advertiser gets refunded. Enforcing this is trivial by the ad network or a neutral third-party scraping the websites running the ads to confirm the ads are displayed properly.
- blooalien 5y ago> "This approach sounds much harder for an ad network to pull off and sounds like it would add a lot of risk and complication. Harder to pull off than advertising at people who might actually want to see the ads? More risk and complication than the growing backlash against advertising in general entirely because of shady advertising practices? More risk and complication than having to keep track of various countries' and states' laws re; privacy? > "For example, what if a web master decides they don't want to have ads on their site anymore. Whoever just paid for that space gets screwed." Existing contract law already covers this in most places. If you paid for ads to be displayed for a certain time period and they are not, then there's been a contract violation.
- blooalien 5y agoThat's actually the way most advertising used to work before all this surveillance stuff started, and still the way it works with some (ethical) advertisers.
- eingaeKaiy8ujie 5y agoThen just post about your IDE on Elixir forums. I'm not interested in seeing any ads on the Internet, and I certainly don't want ad companies that are following me on random websites to know that I'm a programmer who is interested in Elixir or any other data about me.
- charcircuit 5y ago>Then just post about your IDE on Elixir forums. Not all users of Elixir hang out on Elixir forums. There are plenty that spend the majority of their time on the internet elsewhere. >and I certainly don't want ad companies that are following me on random websites to know that I'm a programmer who is interested in Elixir or any other data about me. Why not? Systems can become more efficient if they know you better.
- eingaeKaiy8ujie 5y ago>Why not? Because it's a privacy risk. Such information can be used to identify me and used against me.
- charcircuit 5y ago>Such information can be used to identify me Good. We can make things more efficient. >used against me How could someone for example knowing you like Elixer use that knowledge against you? It's not a big deal.
- eingaeKaiy8ujie 5y agoSuch data can be combined with other bits of information to uniquely identify me on the web. And there may be other facts about me and my online activity that I don't want third parties to associate with my identity.
- justinclift 5y agok, so how about if instead of "Elixer" it was specific religious topics? Or other things that have legal measures for/against them in various parts of the world.
- danbruc 5y agoThis is ridiculous. If I am trying to advertise an Elixer IDE, then I don't want my advertisements shown to any random person on the internet. The majority of users on the internet are not even developers. I want to be able to advertise to a consumer segment which consists of people who are interested in Elixir. "Surveillance" is essential to internet advertising. This is ridiculous. And it is your problem. Why should I allow any company to track and profile me and everyone else only so that you can save on your advertising budget?
- charcircuit 5y agoBecause I don't want to waste the time of people who aren't interested in my ad in seeing my ad. It's a waste of money for me. The ad network will not be able to make money from having them click the ad. The user's time will be wasted because they are not interested in what I am selling. It's a lose lose lose situation. I want to create more win win win situations where everyone benefits. Tracking and profiling is needed to increase the rate that this happens.
- the_other 5y agoYou could target the same people by buying ad space in like-minded “venues”. There’s a gaping hole in the market for good “content-linked” advertising, searching, aggregation and so on. Link to content, not people. Work with customers who’re already self selecting, rather than following people around all the time. As a side-line, this’d probably cut back on a lot of click-bait trash articles. It, likely, would help bring the signal-boise level of the internet at large back to something more useful. Well, I can dream, anyway..
- stevesearer 5y agoThis is what we do at https://officesnapshots.com https://officesnapshots.com and it works pretty well: office furniture ads on office design content.
- blooalien 5y ago
- rotebeete 5y ago> The majority of users on the internet are not even developers. Then just advertise on sites that usually have developers?!
- ncallaway 5y ago> I want to be able to advertise to a consumer segment which consists of people who are interested in Elixir And, as the person being advertised to, I absolutely want you not to be able to do that. Why do your desires trump mine? Surveillance is not essential to internet advertising. Because it’s not essential for advertising. Newspaper ads didn’t come with such invasive models, nor did radio adverts, or even TV ads. If advertisers on the internet can’t figure out how to make a surveillance free advertising model work, then I’d much prefer those businesses to die.
- lallysingh 5y agoNo it's not. It's the same situation that's existed in advertising for decades already. Want to advertise your automotive parts? Advertise in Popular Mechanics. Some fancy clothing? Advertise in Vogue. Now, you just advertise in appropriate blogs. If there are no appropriate publications for important topics, hey! Guess what! They have their business model back!
- eivarv 5y agoMaybe not, but you could show it to people whose context reveal that they might be interested – e.g. searching for "IDE" or "Elixir", reading about developer tools, etc. This is known as contextual advertising. Surveillance is not essential to internet advertising – in fact neither ROI, effectiveness or perceived relevance (when compared to all alternatives, including contextual advertising) has never been proven.
- ricardo81 5y ago> don't want my advertisements shown to any random person on the internet Indeed, win-win that ads are targeted. Easily done on search engines because the query shows intent. Less obvious on the wider web but then perhaps it's the advertisers job to identify their market rather than rely on ad-network datapoints on visitors. CPM/CPC ad payments are of course ripe for abuse by automation. CPA not so much. Could potentially argue that the surveillance is essentially to make targeting more convenient for advertisers rather than being implicitly required to advertise. Market forces and ROI are surely the best measurement which CPA does a better job of doing. The problem with CPA is the trust required in order for the ad network to be paid.
- Nursie 5y ago> This is ridiculous. If I am trying to advertise an Elixer IDE, then I don't want my advertisements shown to any random person on the internet. > I want to be able to advertise to a consumer segment This sounds like a you problem. And you shouldn't get to push surveillance on me to solve it. I don't want to be advertised at at all, let alone be stalked round the web so you can do it better. I don't care at all that any advertising I see might be better targeted, it's all an annoyance as far as I'm concerned anyway. The idea that I should be happier if I'm getting 'relevant' ads, like I should thank you for surveilling me so you can spam me better, is absolutely laughable.
- ashtonkem 5y agoAnd I don’t want you to know my means of employment online. I believe that my right to privacy trumps your economic interest.
- tomjen3 5y agoThat shouldn't be that hard. Doesn't Elexir have a forum, user groups or other place where people self-select for interest in that? Surely you can buy ads in subreddits, or on specific tags on Stack Overflow?
- Woodi 5y agoRadiculous ! Mate, you want one thing so world wide spying is ok for you ? So r. lack in imagination ! Just try to imagine what would be WWW (or other "medium") without that data hoarding... You want to ad IDE, for devs, for particular lang ? Just give money straight to forum of your interests owner. And...... DONE ! Or journal, paper, zine or whatever but do it directly. That businesses curently DO NOT EXIST becose everything goes to Google ! And - biggest stupididy of last two centuries - to "businesesee that "model" enables". Just self serving monopoly giving away penies. You see ? Your "survivalence is necessaary" is just lack of imagination. Literaly, current "system" prohibits new inventions and development. Becouse where are money there are new companies/startups created. End where money are filtered via giant sucker there not much improvement can be build.
- no_time 5y agoI recommend you rethink your advertising strategy. I'd bet over 70% of developers run some kind of adblocker. I personally run adnauseam[0] and I will NEVER click on an ad. [0]: https://adnauseam.io/ https://adnauseam.io/
- dev_tty01 5y ago>"Surveillance" is essential to internet advertising. I think you are missing the point. As a user, my basic response to "my job is harder if I don't do surveillance" is I don't care. If you say that you can't do a certain type of advertising without surveillance, then my response is find another job. There are lots of interesting problems out there to work on for fun and profit. Find another one. Or, stay in advertising and target ads based on what I am doing right now. If I read an online journal about mountaineering, show me ads for mountaineering equipment. Sure, it may be less effective (and boring), but us users are fine with that. Advertisers don't have a right to take away my privacy so they can do what they want. This disconnect keeps coming up over and over. Just because an industry has become large does not inherently make it appropriate.