3 ms·
> The very excellent effect of Ma's downfall is that it will remind wealthy people in the West that democracy has its good points. Yes, like protecting rich cr
by hulitu 5y ago
> The very excellent effect of Ma's downfall is that it will remind wealthy people in the West that democracy has its good points.
Yes, like protecting rich criminals.
> Much easier to sympathize with the expropriation of a Billionaire than some schlub from the middle of nowhere.
Some people never have enough. It is good that sometimes they are shown that limits exist.
- anm89 5y agoNice endorsement of kidnapping and violence against people who have "too much". Fits every criteria of fascism and yet I bet you don't wear that label outwardly.
- lucian1900 5y agoFascism is a tool of the rich to use those fallen from (some amount of) grace against organised labour that might otherwise mount a successful revolution. There’s a reason the first targets have always been communists and labour organisers, not industry owners. Look at what fascists do, not at what they say.
- anm89 5y agoI have no evidence either way of what this person does and they verbally advocate for violence against people they don't like to achieve political ends. So I'm going to stick with them seeming pretty facistic.
- lucian1900 5y agoViolence isn’t inherently fascist. Capitalism uses violence against the working class to maintain profits for the owning class. Revolutions of the working class are violent, yet they end the former violence and exploitation. Fascism is violence to protect the owning class from a revolution by the working class. Suppression of capitalists after a working class revolution is also violence to prevent them from regaining power to yet again use violence to exploit the working class. Violence is just one way to exert power.
- anm89 5y agoI'll stick with that being fascism. Feel free to debate semantics all you want. It's not the important part of the argument.
- lucian1900 5y agoThe meanings of words matter if we are to understand each other. Fascism has a very specific historical meaning. Violence is a far more general concept.
- anm89 5y agoRight. And what he's talking about is fascism so I'm calling it fascism.
- lucian1900 5y agoNot at all, no. They’re talking about a workers’ state using violence against a capitalist exploiter. If it was a billionaire calling for former small business owners to attack organised labour, that’d be fascism.
- kzzzznot 5y agoIs Jack Ma a criminal? And to your second point, are you saying that it is good to threaten, silence or disappear wealthy people in case they might become a threat to your authoritarian regime? I suppose from a purely practical point of view yes that might be the best move. We seem to disagree on the ethics of authoritarianism though.