10 ms·
I think we give magic mushrooms FDA approved based on your anecdote.
by refurb 5y ago
I think we give magic mushrooms FDA approved based on your anecdote.
- grayhatter 5y agoThis isn't the first time I've heard this. There's plenty of other sources that seem to corroborate this anecdote; and let's all not forget. The plural of anecdote is evidence. All that said, actually waiting for FDA approval does seem a lot less risky
- carlmr 5y ago>The plural of anecdote is evidence. While I find the anecdotes compelling. I would assume that to make multiple anecdotes evidence you'd have to at least register these anecdotes systematically, otherwise you only hear the extreme ones that people like to tell.
- grayhatter 5y agoYeah, that's my bad. I meant to say data, not evidence. But you'll note that I didn't weight the quality of it. Anecdotes (plural) are data points, interpretation of them is left to whomever wants to use said data. A temperature sensor that you know isn't desiged to work at subzero is reporting -30 consistently. It may be -40 or -20 but you know it's below zero. Someone reporting symptom relief from depression, (which is something who's most severe symptoms are by definition subjective,) after taking psilocybin is a good data point. It without a doubt has helped. Why, how, and discovery of caveats notwithstanding; it's something worthy of understanding, and with anecdotes (plural) consideration for use * . Just because the picture is incomplete, doesn't devalue the existing data points. Which is the thing I was trying to push back on. My data points may be weak, or noisy. But my data points are worth more than your scepticism. Full disclosure, I'm a card carrying sceptic saying that. I always think there's more to be understood, but merely devaluing the data points you currently have is not the way to go about it. Ask questions, don't raise complaints. * : some restrictions apply
- corobo 5y agoThe plural of anecdote should be hypothesis
- dmos62 5y agoAnecdotal: report of clinical experiences based on individual experience, rather than an organized investigation with standard research features, such as appropriate controls. https://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/anecdotal https://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/anecdotal I think it's fair to say that medical research is not scaled up anecdotes.