4 ms·
If I've understood correctly, the denominator being compared against isn't a "best available alternative" treatment solution of H2O2. It's against the concentra
by perihelions 5y ago
If I've understood correctly, the denominator being compared against isn't a "best available alternative" treatment solution of H2O2. It's against the concentration that's an "equivalent amount"-- which is actually a pretty dilute concentration (for H2O2), that *isn't* effectively bactericidal.
>"...are over 10^7 times more potent than an equivalent amount of preformed hydrogen peroxide..."
Per fig. 2(c,d), the "commercial H2O2" items are solutions of 100 and 200 ppm (0.01% / 0.02%), and have nearly zero effect (less than 1 order-of-magnitude reduction in bacterial/viral viability).
([edit]: or quoting the paper itself: "These standardized preformed H2O2 samples, produced either commercially or catalytically (100–200ppm), exhibited limited bactericidal activity [my emphasis] against...")
Their actual point is that this H2O2+ROS is highly effective at a concentration at which H2O2 alone is not effective.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/352882305_A_residue-free_approach_to_water_disinfection_using_catalytic_in_situ_generation_of_reactive_oxygen_species https://www.researchgate.net/publication/352882305_A_residue...
~~~~~
[edit]: In attempt to find further context, here's some data about disinfection with H2O2 solutions (in entirely different experimental setups which probably have important caveats I don't know):
>"...organisms with high cellular catalase activity (e.g., S. aureus, S. marcescens, and Proteus mirabilis) required 30–60 minutes of exposure to 0.6% hydrogen peroxide for a 10^8 reduction in cell counts, whereas organisms with lower catalase activity (e.g., E. coli, Streptococcus species, and Pseudomonas species) required only 15 minutes’ exposure [657]..."
https://www.cdc.gov/infectioncontrol/pdf/guidelines/disinfection-guidelines-H.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/infectioncontrol/pdf/guidelines/disinfec... (page 47)
So, as a hand-waving non-expert: it looks like you can get the same order of magnitude of effect (factor of 10^8 bacterial reduction) as the stuff in the OP paper, at a hydrogen peroxide concentration that's ~60 times higher than what OP uses (0.6% = 6000 ppm). (?)
- lugged 5y ago> The team showed that as the catalyst brought the hydrogen and oxygen together to form hydrogen peroxide, it simultaneously produced a number of highly reactive compounds, known as reactive oxygen species (ROS), which the team demonstrated were responsible for the antibacterial and antiviral effect, and not the hydrogen peroxide itself. > The catalyst-based method was shown to be 10,000,000 times more potent at killing the bacteria than an equivalent amount of the industrial hydrogen peroxide, and over 100,000,000 times more effective than chlorination, under equivalent conditions. Basically, I'm getting the highly reactive ROS are the key point here, they're creating them in situ so they're able to be exploited where as standing h2o2 is likely much less reactive. The order of magnitude gains are easy to grasp if you take into consideration the literal hours you need to wait for chlorine or similar to sterilize water. If there is a way to speed that up to near instant your gains are going to be relatively immeasurable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- slownews45 5y agoThey are testing against E Coli which is an easy target. My understand was always that E Coli is on the order of 1 minute. If you are into camping you might be thinking of things like Giardia - much harder to kill.
- engineer_22 5y agoCl cant kill Giardia oocysts, they have to be filtered out.
- slownews45 5y agoChlorine is effective against Giardia. It requires longer exposure periods generally and can be temp dependent (ie, 1 hr vs 1 minute).
- engineer_22 5y agoYes, that's right. Cryptosporidium, another common parasite, is much more resistant to Chlorine
- slownews45 5y agoFantastic job looking into this. This is actually my point exactly. This may not be 100,000,000x better in a practical sense. It is maybe 60x better but because they are doing math with something that is a zero (or close too it) they get to report an insane increase in effectiveness. It's actually a great tell for what is often garbage analysis when you have this level of a multiple.