4 ms·
> Punishing unmarried couples didn't increase the number of stable partnerships at all. That’s a bad example. Family stability plummeted after the sexual revol
by rayiner 5y ago
> Punishing unmarried couples didn't increase the number of stable partnerships at all.
That’s a bad example. Family stability plummeted after the sexual revolution, even as access to birth control and abortion made family planning easier: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_parents_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_parents_in_the_United_S...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 5y agoI don't know that the sexual revolution correlation holds up as well as the liberalization of divorce laws, which precedes the sex stuff by a decade or more.
- ww2buff 5y agoI think it is a remarkable testament to your patience that you continue to treat this guy as if he is interested in arguing in good faith, and not as a hardcore ideologue & culture-warrior.
- tptacek 5y agoThis guy is one of the most valuable contributors to the site, all the more so because we disagree about so much politically; I have almost total faith that he means what he says, and, especially on politically-tinged topics (also compiler theory), tend to learn a lot from him. Always happy for the opportunity to say that, so thanks!
- rayiner 5y agoI’ll admit to being a gun nut and originalist, but “breakdown of two parent families is bad” is a completely mainstream position among non-white immigrants in the US.
- myWindoonn 5y agoHacker News invites paleoconservatives, neoconservatives, reactionaries, fascists, etc. because the moderation team and owners are cryptofascists. It's that simple. To quote Genesis, they know what they like and they like what they know.
- rayiner 5y agoI agree changing attitudes towards divorce was the main factor. I was imprecise in my wording, I was fishing for phraseology that would encompass both.
- lostdog 5y ago"Let's trap people in bad marriages" is exactly the social infrastructure I'm criticizing.
- rayiner 5y agoWhat’s a “bad marriage?” I think there are some that are truly bad and should be dissolved. But I think in many cases (perhaps the majority), people are simply indulging their own selfishness and poor impulse control at the expense of their kids. Americans highly prioritize (to my eyes, as a foreigner, childish) notions of self actualization and individual happiness over duty to family. And then there’s the kids whose parents never got married, typically because the father is stuck in some sort of extended adolescence. My siblings in law come from one of those middle/lower middle class primarily white towns you sometimes read about, where two-parent families have declined tremendously. The devastation to the kids is real. Comfortable finances dissolve into financial strain. Lack of stability affects kids’ performance in school. Boys, in particular, suffer growing up without fathers to keep them in line. (It wasn’t until I had boys of my own that I realized how differently they often relate to their mothers versus their fathers. And trust me, we’re not modeling traditional gender roles at my house—my wife’s a scary trial lawyer who pays our mortgage.)
- cpach 5y agoInteresting reflections. It probably goes hand in hand with the US culture where individual mobility (both geographically and economically) seems to be highly regarded (which also has many positive effects). I live in Sweden. Since the late 19th century or so, and especially after WW2, we’re very influenced by the US and I can see the same tendencies here.
- 5y ago