3 ms·
The feature that has been lost was actually a property of writing checks. When you use a debit card, or use a website to make an online payment, you're ultimate
by mindslight 5y ago
The feature that has been lost was actually a property of writing checks. When you use a debit card, or use a website to make an online payment, you're ultimately asking permission and the bank is free to say "no" with little repercussion. Whereas if you write a check on your account, pass it to someone else, who passes it to their bank, who presents it to your bank, your bank wantonly dishonoring the check would result in a much larger fallout.
Push transactions also put the paying bank on the hook for whether the transaction was fraudulent or not. Whereas with a pull transaction, it is up to the receiving bank to clean up the mess from any fraud. This is why banks (especially smaller banks) will put daily limit on the ACH transfers you can initiate, but will process whatever externally-initiated ACHs land on your account.
- gruez 5y ago>Whereas if you write a check on your account, pass it to someone else, who passes it to their bank, who presents it to your bank, your bank wantonly dishonoring the check would result in a much larger fallout. I doubt that the law would be on your side if the bank called and told you that your account was closed, and you continued writing checks. At best that would prevent situations mentioned in the article where your account was frozen without your notice, but you'll still be out $10k while that's being resolved.
- mindslight 5y agoYes, obviously if you have received notice your account is closed, and you continue writing checks, you're on the hook for writing bad checks. The point is that any in flight checks would cause a problem for the banks, which discourages traditional banks from adopting "innovative" ideas like freezing accounts en masse based on machine learning snake oil.
- gruez 5y ago>The point is that any in flight checks would cause a problem for the banks, which discourages traditional banks from adopting "innovative" ideas like freezing accounts en masse based on machine learning snake oil. Is this what's happening here? The way I read the story it sounded like they froze the account and then the customer only noticed because her card was declined, rather than her account being frozen because she tried to use it. Even if the banks couldn't do "in flight checks" (because people use checks rather than debit cards), it doesn't prevent them from using "machine learning snake oil" to randomly close accounts.
- mindslight 5y agoI didn't say that it prevents banks from closing accounts, rather they're discouraged. If a bank really thinks an account is fraudulent, they need to stop processing checks drawn on the account. Since doing so creates fallout they have to deal with, they're incentivized to only declare an account fraudulent if they're pretty damn sure. Whereas with a totally online account, the only downside is losing that customer.