6 ms·
The fork of Audacity due to some questionable changes[1] is here: https://github.com/temporary-audacity/audacity https://github.com/temporary-audacity/audacity.
by johnisgood 5y ago
The fork of Audacity due to some questionable changes[1] is here: https://github.com/temporary-audacity/audacity https://github.com/temporary-audacity/audacity. It already has 2k stars.
Telemetry for Audacity: https://github.com/audacity/audacity/pull/835 https://github.com/audacity/audacity/pull/835
The issue about the Privacy Policy (related to the above): https://github.com/audacity/audacity/issues/1213 https://github.com/audacity/audacity/issues/1213
[1] Description of the fork: Audacity Fork without any Sentry Telemetry or Crash Reporting.
- gsich 5y agoThe same problem with forks still stands. People are eager to fork something because they don't like X. But maintaining it?
- forgotpwd16 5y agoDepends on whether is a soft or hard fork. Do they just want to have a version that closely tracks upstream but removing/adding specific features or be an independent project? The former is more maintainable (see ungoogled-chromium, VSCodium, ...).
- reikonomusha 5y agoI don’t trust that people who know how to delete telemetry code are also people who know how to build and maintain advanced audio/signal processing code. It seems more reasonable to try to work diplomatically to get the changes the public wants to see upstream instead of forking and crossing one’s fingers that the fork is kosher.
- Tepix 5y agoAudacity is GPL, they can merge the upstream commits after removing the tracking.
- Hamcha 5y agoThis is only valid as long as the project remains GPL licensed. Musegroup has a new CLA and said that they made it sign to all past contributors, which allows them the right to relicense the product as they fit. While the fact that their privacy policy/telemetry infringes on the GPL (since it restricts use for people under 13) might not be enough to warrant a license change (though I guess it should? It's infringing it after all), they have their hands permanently on the rug we're all standing on and they can pull it whenever they want. Popular example of this happening is Aseprite, it was relicensed from GPL to EULA. The code is still open source, but the FOSS fork cannot just take the new changes and port them over.
- neltnerb 5y agoIf they do this, and improve the program enough, then it seems like a reasonable outcome that in exchange for using non-GPL versions of the code you have to agree to their tracking. And if the people that are now freely contributing code to that project to handle audio decide that they don't want their changes to be licensed in a proprietary way, well, we get a new LibreOffice... people maintaining GPL software for free/cheap seems a lot more likely than maintaining software that is proprietary and owned by some company that is uninterested in sharing the improvements they submit.
- nemetroid 5y ago> Musegroup has a new CLA and said that they made it sign to all past contributors, which allows them the right to relicense the product as they fit. Wow, adding a CLA is much more egregious than adding telemetry. I'm disappointed that it hasn't received nearly as much attention on HN. I wish they'd gone for a DCO. https://drewdevault.com/2021/04/12/DCO.html https://drewdevault.com/2021/04/12/DCO.html
- woodrowbarlow 5y agoi don't think the fork maintainers intend to do active development. i assume they intend to stay up-to-date with upstream, with only enough modifications to remove the tracking code. as for legitimacy, there really is no question that the fork is within the rights of the license.
- nescioquid 5y agoWould the fork, accepting changes from upstream, also accept changes that originated from telemetry information? I can imagine a principled stand which says the fork would not commit any changes driven or informed by telemetry data, though it is not clear how that could be done. Failing that, it sounds more like "don't track me, but I'm happy to benefit from those who are" (which is effectively the same situation as opting-out of the telemetry).
- iseethroughbs 5y agoThe original Audacity is open source, so the fork maintainers don't need to be good at audio code.
- loxias 5y agoHear Hear! Solidly agree. You'd be amazed how much can go into "simple" resampling... if you care about being accurate, anyway. Though... and I say this with a mischievous grin, as someone who writes signal processing code (specializing in audio) for both leisure and employment, I've been wanting to get Audacity squarely in my emacs, and just go nuts, with both mathematically cogent improvements and plenty of unnecessary petty stylistic refactoring, for YEARS (decades). Now, perhaps I have some protective cover. ;-) (unless Monty beats me to it...)
- CharlesW 5y ago> You'd be amazed how much can go into "simple" resampling... if you care about being accurate, anyway. Audacity is "My First Audio Editor", and people use it primarily because it's free. Quality is not a concern. Audacity is a great entry point for people who are new to audio production, but those users eventually graduate to better, more fit-for-task audio tools.
- jaywalk 5y agoYou are correct about Audacity being used primarily because it's free, and it's certainly very far from professional audio software. But I think it's pretty unfair to say that quality isn't a concern, because I'm sure that the developers care very much about quality.
- handrous 5y agoWe have the word spyware, and we used to use it. It applied to software with "telemetry" before creepster marketing dweebs made recording your users' mouse movements and key-logging them on your website fucking normal so a little "telemetry" seems downright tame by comparison. Software with telemetry is spyware.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoThere's a distinct difference; software with telemetry gathers how you use that particular application, spyware gathers everything you do with your computer. Which is why Windows' telemetry is so controversial. I'm OK with telemetry as long as it's not a communications platform and doesn't forward any work (e.g. code, audio files) I do with it. Telemitry like what buttons or keyboard shortcuts I use, summarized into statistics are fine. I'm not OK with spyware.
- btown 5y agoFor creativity software, there's a fine line between "what keyboard shortcuts do I press" and "can the sequence of what I'm typing be captured and recreated, and used to target me or steal my work." Muse Group could have laid down very specific ground rules: telemetry will always be opt-in, you'll be able to audit exactly what is sent, it will never contain low-level keystroke information, it will be anonymized before being saved into our database and be impossible to associate with a cloud user login. That would be the opposite of spyware! But they didn't set these ground rules, and now they have this entire uprising on their hands. I'd like to give them the opportunity to do right and learn from this experience. But they also need a wake-up call that they need to work to earn back the community's trust.
- inetknght 5y ago> There's a distinct difference; software with telemetry gathers how you use that particular application That is spyware. How I use an application should not be anyone's business. It's a hop-skip-and-a-jump to learn private information from how software is used. For example: do you hover your mouse over an icon? Do you let it linger for a unique amount of time? Do you have a particular writing style? Do you have a particular time between each keystroke? When you crash the application do you just re-open it or go do something different? Do you exit the application cleanly or do you power off the computer? Do you use the application without a license? Does your computer clock magically change? Does your computer location move? Do you travel between cities a lot, or even countries? Do you interact with the application in one location but leave it in the background in another location? Do you talk while the application is in use? Do your eyes follow your cursor? Are your eyes looking at the application while you're using it? Do you talk about other products while using the application? ALL of this is private information. Telemetry is just a hop-skip-and-a-jump to data mining.