3 ms·
I dislike people calling the GPL "viral". The thing that is viral is copyright. Copyright is baked into law and nobody can escape it. If you relinquish your own
by globular-toast 5y ago
I dislike people calling the GPL "viral". The thing that is viral is copyright. Copyright is baked into law and nobody can escape it. If you relinquish your own copyright then as soon as someone modifies the work copyright comes back. Copyleft is the only antidote we have for copyright. All Stallman et al really want is to "switch off" copyright. That would be obvious if people would listen to his talks. But instead we get a bunch of people thinking the GPL is "more restrictive" but what they really mean is "I want copyright for myself but not for you". Maybe copyleft was a mistake and we should really just fight copyright directly.
- jeroenhd 5y agoI consider the viral thing of copyright a good thing, similar to a meme going viral. While technically the law, people were pretty upset when a "meme tax" was being discussed because the copyright owners of the sources of many memes were seeking compensation. The idea of going viral as making it something everyone can partake in and something nobody can tell you not to do as long as you don't try to restrict others is pretty positive. Companies and copyright firms will have us believe the "viral" just refers to the way COVID is viral, but it's become more than that. Any company advocating against or complaining about GPL isn't worth paying attention to, in my opinion. In this case, the one of an individual developer, that's not the case though. Not everyone who chooses GPL wants to kill copyright, especially people in the game dev world whose entire business is that of copyright. For those people, GPL is the wrong license to release their source code by for many reasons, though it's also the right license to release their source code by for many others. I've always seen copyleft as a fight against copyright, an abuse of the system meant to accumulate private wealth and restrictions, by forcing people to give up their private gains or make them reinvent the wheel if they wish to keep their IP to themselves. Any patent owner will say IP is necessary for the market to stay competitive, anyone who's ever had to buy patents (media codecs, mobile communication, etc) or who's been sued by patent trolls will likely say that patents stifle innovation instead. It's all about what you gain personally. I like the idea of copyright for individuals, but corporate copyright as a thing that can be sold, bought, or pooled, has been so terribly restrictive to most of the world that I'm in favour of a massive reform.
- globular-toast 5y agoMost reasonable people agree that copyright on creative works is a good thing, but it has to be short. 10 years is plenty. What we currently have is "life plus 70 years"! That means well over 100 years. 100 years! It's totally insane, but most people just don't question it. Are we really to believe that there is anyone out there encouraged to write because they know their work will still be copyrighted for 70 years after they die?
- shagie 5y agoLets take your 10 years one... If a work loses its copyright after 10 years, I could grab emacs 23.3 and make some changes and release it all close source. Or gcc 4.6.1. iText became AGPL in '09.. version 5.1.1 was released 10 years ago (5.5.13 is current) and it could be brought to a closed source library. Whats more, I believe that the photographs that I took 10 years ago still have as much value as the day that I took them. There are a lot of photographers who's livelihood is based on their library of photographs that they have taken over the years. --- Lifetime plus 70 was done in the era where publishing content had a very long tail and the estate (and children) were able to collect from that long tail for their lifetime too. While I'm in agreement that lifetime + 70 is too much, I believe that 10 is far too little. -- A prediction / alternate world -- if copyright was 10 years on software, you'd get an EaaS model - everything as a service. You wouldn't have anything that you could install. No libraries - nothing. You make calls out to services to do whatever you need. This would likely include connecting to VMs controlled by large companies from rather low powered terminals. Yes, this looks a lot like chrome books and the cloud for everything.
- globular-toast 5y agoCopyright is a complicated thing and I don't pretend to have all the answers. I'm not suggesting to simply reduce the length of copyright and keep everything else the same. I would like to see copyright on software gone completely. Software has a unique purpose in our lives and should not be treated like other creative works such as music and literature. I believe software development would still be good business without the protection of copyright. Vendors could focus on documentation and support rather than the code itself. > There are a lot of photographers who's livelihood is based on their library of photographs that they have taken over the years. There are a lot of people whose livelihood is based on crime. This isn't a valid argument for what is right or wrong. Copyright is supposed to encourage new works for the greater good of society. This is written into the US Constitution, no less. It would be interesting to see if lengthening the term of copyright has caused an increase in the number or quality of creative works being produced. I highly doubt that it has. > A prediction / alternate world -- if copyright was 10 years on software, you'd get an EaaS model - everything as a service. Why would it change anything for existing free/open-source software? We'd still have GNU/Linux and the BSDs. If it made proprietary software even worse, then so be it. More reason to use free software.
- trasz 5y agoErm, but it is GPL that’s being viral. Not copyright, and also not other Open Source licenses - just GPL. That’s why you won’t get a license incompatibility problem without GPL in the mix.
- globular-toast 5y agoIf you modify a public domain work, copyright comes back. If we're using virus analogies then copyright is like a retrovirus. Forever baked into the "DNA" of our legal systems and you can never be rid of it. I think, like many people, you consider copyright to be like some unquestionable right. But it's not. It was invented about 400 years ago and it's way out of date. We can and should question it. If you can't think about copyright, you won't understand copyleft.
- trasz 5y agoDoes that copyright, coming back, have any actual consequences? What people mean by virality is not some copyright coming back; it's the fact that GPL "spreads" via linking. And that does have consequences: it's where license incompatibility comes from, and it's also why you can't use GPL-ed code with code under other (Open Source) licenses.
- globular-toast 5y agoThe GPL is only as powerful as copyright. GPL relies on copyright to "spread". Copyright is the virus. GPL just uses the virus against itself in a very clever way.
- mannerheim 5y agoGPL 'spreads' via linking because copyright spreads via linking. If you write a program and I link to it, we both own the resulting work. Your copyright has 'infected' the work. The license in this case can be anything, even a proprietary one, so it isn't the GPL that's special here. License incompatibilities are certainly possible with proprietary licenses, there's nothing special about the GPL (or copyleft) from other copyright licenses that grants it magical incompatibility properties. Someone could license you software only to use in industry A while somebody else forbids you from using their software in that industry. There are also plenty of non-free licenses that require use to be non-commercial that could face a similar problem.
- lucian1900 5y agoAbsolutely. It’s not the only antidote to copyright, though. Dismantling the current legal system that is designed to protect profits above human need could solve the problem more permanently.
- marcodiego 5y agoI don't like "viral" or "infects" terms because they are kind of derogatory. It is better to explain that derivative works must be under the same license.
- coaksford 5y agoGPL uses copyright and its viral aspects strongly to try to undermine copyright's goals. That's precisely why it is viral, because it is copyright, and doesn't make it any less viral. BSD-style licenses' terms minimize the viral impact of copyright on the free use of the covered work rather than trying to maximize that viral tendency toward achieving some opposing goal. The distinction still works fine. GPL is viral, as contrasted with BSD licenses, but not as contrasted with proprietary copyright, and for the same reasons.