4 ms·
As I said, these SJWs and "AI ethics" researchers have not invented the idea of minimizing the number of mistakes ML systems make. Yes, you can point out that
by biasedbrain 5y ago
As I said, these SJWs and "AI ethics" researchers have not invented the idea of minimizing the number of mistakes ML systems make.
Yes, you can point out that perhaps a data set is missing some black faces, but that should be a minor bug entry in the bug tracker, not a million dollar industry getting people PhDs.
And "those people" are not stopping at providing better data sets, they want to introduce their own political bias into the system, literally creating a distorted view of the world. As I said, this is serious stuff, if you assume most people will perceive the world via Google searches.
Maybe the issue here is "known problems" - this is not about "known problems", it is about a specific ideology that makes them believe they "know" what causes certain problems. As a simplified example, they want to make the AI "not see color" and think that will make the problems go away. Forcing the AI (and in turn the people who use it) to not see color is totalitarian control and wrong.
Decision making is an issue, but that needs to be addressed at the human level, not in the tools that are being used to perceive the world.
If you AI discovers that women historically have been worse hires for your company (or people doing the hiring thought they were worse), the correct response is not to introduce some artificial bias in the ML to ignore gender or inflate the scores for women. It is to try to figure out what has been going on, and to make up your mind what you actually want.
- civilized 5y ago> As a simplified example, they want to make the AI "not see color" and think that will make the problems go away. I promise you that is the exact opposite of what they want.
- biasedbrain 5y agoTrue, in a way, as they want to artificially inflate those scores. As I said, it was a simplified example. The bottom line is they want to hardcode their politics into the algorithm.