3 ms·
The only expense for excess storage, above capital cost of the tankage, is refrigeration to compensate for heat leakage through the insulation. All the tradeof
by ncmncm 5y ago
The only expense for excess storage, above capital cost of the tankage, is refrigeration to compensate for heat leakage through the insulation.
All the tradeoffs, together, are an optimization problem that is not hard to solve for conditions found. Since the ultimate source of power, solar, is the cheapest ever devised, they start with a huge advantage. It would be foolish to bet against them.
- Retric 5y agoSure, but it’s an optimization problem up against simply building more solar. That’s the part of the equation most armchair experts are ignoring. Excess solar production is basically guaranteed due to how cheap it is. It’s likely that some long term storage is optional, but at scale it’s likely to be relatively small percentage.
- ncmncm 5y agoMore solar generates power only when the sun is shining. This apparatus is for use mainly when the sun is not shining, or when it is not shining enough. Sometimes the sun barely penetrates the clouds, and then you need a boost all day. Maybe it would be cheaper to import power from a dam in Paraguay than to keep your tanks full and cold until you need it. But it might be cheaper to buy power only if they know you don't really need to. Energy economics are more complicated than we can safely generalize about here. The safe bet is that somebody spending $150M has thought it through.
- Retric 5y agoSure but note they didn’t get more than 10 hours of storage from this system. It’s designed to have close to zero long term storage like every single grid backup system currently in production. Something like 20% reserve capacity is completely rational, but you get there by having redundant daily storage so having one or more of them going online doesn’t break the grid.
- ncmncm 5y agoYou can always add more reserve capacity if you find uses for it.