5 ms·
The premise of Wooden's methods is that the players already have a lot of experience playing basketball. Many many games by the time they got to UCLA. Informal
by brudgers 5y ago
The premise of Wooden's methods is that the players already have a lot of experience playing basketball. Many many games by the time they got to UCLA. Informal and formal.
And that's my caveat for this as advice on painting. If a person doesn't already have a history of painting, by which I mean starting and completing paintings as paintings, no amount of drill is going turn them into a painter. The willingness to execute paintings has to be there.
- runevault 5y agoI think the key is that you have to spend some time doing the entire thing, but you have to be willing to go back and rework your fundamentals in smaller chunks (examples from the article being anything from composition to eyeing distances to color mixing).
- rahimnathwani 5y agoThe 'wax on, wax off' drill worked for Daniel Laruso in The Karate Kid.
- yellow_lead 5y agoYes, but that was a movie.
- temp234 5y agoDoes anybody have any reading recommendations or thoughts on the topic of how people _with_ drilled or otherwise refined skills can turn into people who come up with and complete mature creative projects? In creative contexts I know a lot of people who get stuck on just drilling their skills forever or who want to be mature creative project-completers but mysteriously aren't getting it done. I've read a lot about how people get world-class good at things ("10k hours") but I don't think those books explain why one person successfully completes a unique comic, album, short film, or novella and another person struggles with that goal all their days, either only producing derivative work or never completing their work. Some of the focus on "10k'ing" your way to world class skill feels like a distraction from developing as an independent thing-finisher. Some incredible creative work has been completed by people with decent-but-not-world-class skill.
- brudgers 5y agoFor art, it’s not skill or technique that makes someone an artist. It is simply the terrifying decision that what you make is art. Terrifying because the only gatekeeper to being an artist is you. Declare yourself an artist and you are. Call what you made art and it is.
- chris_st 5y agoYup. When I was painting, I spent some time thinking about what it "meant" to be an artist. I finally decided that an artist is just executing a vision in some particular medium.
- blindmute 5y agoIt is however skill and technique that in large part makes someone a good artist. Like it or not, art is a physically skilled medium.
- brudgers 5y agoThere is no such thing as good and bad artists. That’s what makes the decision terrifying.
- blindmute 5y agoThere definitely is such thing, and claiming otherwise is a weird, very recent trend.
- brudgers 5y agoVan Gogh is why there aren’t. There are establishment artists and folk artists and lots of oblique trajectories off that axis but that’s not good and bad. Or as Harry Truman opined. “If that’s art, I’m a Hottentotte.”
- mabub24 5y agoYou are relatively correct. The 10k "rule" and other general guidelines are just that --- guidelines for something that often bucks guidelines and is better for it. 3 things an artist make: 1. Finishing and finishing often. You should not be making the same thing all the time, but you should be consciously iterating in any direction you like as long as you are still finishing. Great painters, writers, musicians, are constantly making stuff, you only see the polished stuff that ends up through the filter. 2. Studying the great works in whatever your chosen field/style/genre. Know the "rules", the normal directions on the map, before you break them and decide on a shortcut or to buck convention all together. All great artists, even the enfant-terrible avant-garde artists, are extremely knowledgeable in art-history in their chosen field and can explain extremely precise opinions on the merits of one artist or movement. Most postures of naiveté are just that: posturing. Great artists know their stuff. 3. Surrounding yourself with other artists. You need people who will look at whatever you finish and tell you about it. Hopefully, these people should be as interested in good art as you, and as well versed or more well versed in art history as you. Engaging in communities of artists will make your imagination and creativity soar. You absolutely need 1 and 2. You can get by without 3, but you will likely never achieve true greatness without it. Everything else after that is luck.
- khazhoux 5y agoI think you're extrapolating his advice into something it's not. He is advocating a way to improve (by focusing on narrow tasks and skills), and he never says this will turn your into a painter. But if you are a painter (or whatever) then don't always be in "performance" mode, because that limits improvement.
- arkj 5y agoThe will to do the drill will bring the willingness to execute. I am not a painter but I followed a pure drill approach to teach html/css/javascript to 12 of my operations/monitoring team members (11 males 1 female, aged 24-27) who lost their job during start of Covid. None of them had any background in programming or engineering, 3 of them dropped out after two weeks. All those who went through the drill got jobs as developers. 7 as react developers, 1 test automation and 1 script developer. All I did was ensure the drill and motivate them not to give up. They were all from very poor families so the motivation part was easy - hope of a better life at the end of drill. The mantra is, don’t fool yourself, type it, clock the hours and don’t miss the meeting.