4 ms·
"... and I can't see how the situation can be improved, at least for quite some time." I can. But no one is going to listen to either of us, so what does it m
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
"... and I can't see how the situation can be improved, at least for quite some time."
I can. But no one is going to listen to either of us, so what does it matter.
Here is how I would start to improve the situation.
Disconnect untrusted computers from the internet.
In other words the only computer that is allowed to access the internet directly is a computer that has all the properties desired for adequate security. Those properties could be things like the hardware being repairable, having an open BIOS and the bootloader and OS being open source and able to be compiled from source by the user easily. Call this computer a "gateway" if you like, or call it a "firewall", or call it whatever you want to call it. The esential point is that it is the one computer you believe you can best understand and control.
I would be willing to bet any amount of money that just disconnecting all Windows computers from the internet, i.e., no direct connection, would result in a dramatic drop in security problems.
Keyloggers are not very useful on a mass scale if they cannot transfer the keystrokes over the internet.
There was a time when not all computers had unfettered direct access to the internet. They worked just fine. Maybe even better than ones today that are incessantly trying to connect to some server.
- est31 5y agoMost popular Linux distros are in many ways more vulnerable than Windows. Microsoft employs actual security engineers for Windows. To give one example, X11 is still in wide use. The secure Linux distros are all of the locked down kind, like Chrome OS and Android. The reason why we aren't seeing widespread desktop Linux malware campaigns is because almost nobody uses desktop Linux. The year of the Linux desktop, whenever it will be, will be followed by the year of the Linux desktop malware. I love open source and free software, but it's not inherently more secure.
- iratewizard 5y agoLinux is still under 2% of the market share for anyone wondering.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoMarket share for desktops of course ;)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ploxiln 5y agoYou might be surprised to find that Windows has a similar problem to X11 - any GUI window can send messages to any other GUI window, and on consumer versions of windows you can't use multiple simultaneous user sessions to separate different applications. https://invisiblethingslab.com/resources/2014/A%20crack%20on%20the%20glass.pdf https://invisiblethingslab.com/resources/2014/A%20crack%20on... It's true that windows has way more mitigation technologies, and X11 is more laissez-faire. But if you don't run untrusted or crappy software, linux can be pretty damn good. You just don't really know how crappy all the components of windows really are, or which mitigations are really useful or really working correctly, and in software with that much complexity there's always some stuff that isn't really working and nobody notices. In linux, if you really care, you can trim down to a very minimal curated setup, and that's really the only way to know what's really going on in your computer.
- saghm 5y ago> I would be willing to bet any amount of money that just disconnecting all Windows computers from the internet, i.e., no direct connection, would result in a dramatic drop in security problems Given how many security problems come from the internet, I imagine that there would be a dramatic drop in security problems if any platform with as much popularity as usage as was cut off from contacting other machines over the internet, even if the platform had above average security.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoAlthough there is a reason I said Windows and not some OS that can be trimmed down and compiled from source by the user (not necessarily GNU/Linux, there are others), it does not matter so much what is the "platform" (I presume you mean OS) nor its popularity. The idea is that fewer of each user's computers, no matter what kernel they run, would be able to directly contact other computers over the internet.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tourist2d 5y ago> Disconnect untrusted computers from the internet. Disconnect billions of devices? How would you even enforce this? > I would be willing to bet any amount of money that just disconnecting all Windows computers from the internet, i.e., no direct connection, would result in a dramatic drop in security problems. Not really sure I understand your point here. Why stop at just Windows? If we remove all computers from the internet we would be so much more secure. I'm also not sure why you single out Windows when even the blog post demonstrates this key logger in Linux (which is open source). > There was a time when not all computers had unfettered direct access to the internet. They worked just fine. Maybe even better than ones today that are incessantly trying to connect to some server. I hope this is a troll rather than someone honestly believing such a statement. You're claiming disconnected computers are perhaps better... while writing on one connected to the internet.
- 3np 5y ago> while writing on one connected to the internet. I think you’re missing part of their point (which isn’t super clear). You can still surf on such a computer, by going through an http proxy on the same LAN (the “gateway” they’re talking about, or bastion host) They could very much be writing that comment on such a machine.
- infinite8s 5y agoSo they are saying to use a firewall...
- 3np 5y agoMore specifically, that the host should not route public IP space but use a proxy for any outbound connection (and a load balancer/reverse proxy for any incoming) Every org is different of course but in the general I agree that this should be a more common pattern.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoThis is the idea. Amazing how people can (mis)interpret (unclear) comments as if they were crystal clear. They make assumptions. They read things in that are not there. It is truly entertaining, I never mentioned Linux. I never mentioned "desktop". Nor did I suggest Windows users would not be able to access the internet. Nor did I suggest the computer with IP forwarding enabled (call it what you like) needs to do everything a "firewall" does. Indeed, I am writing this comment on such a commputer that runs a proxy for all the other computers. That's only because I like to experiment with different proxy configs.