3 ms·
It's almost a tautology - by definition, if you're employed, you're skilled (at whatever skill the employer was looking to get). If you were 'skilled' in somet
by mgkimsal 15y ago
It's almost a tautology - by definition, if you're employed, you're skilled (at whatever skill the employer was looking to get). If you were 'skilled' in something an employer no longer needs, then you become unemployed. Are you 'less skilled' in the absolute sense? Probably not, but from the previous employer's POV, you're not skilled (in what they need).
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 15y agoThe complete tautology is that you are skilled at remaining employed. There are plenty of instances, eras, locations, and industries in which the pool of employable individuals is radically smaller than those who are qualified for a position. Most generally, those exclusions are based on social factors: skin color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, age, social background, social connections, and others. While Silicon Valley in particular is vastly more meritocratic than many cases, and you'll find a broad diversity especially among East Asian, Indian, Israeli, and eastern European backgrounds, there's still a marked under-representation of blacks and hispanic/latinos (the latter particularly notable given the huge hispanic population in the Bay Area). There is also a fair amount of grumbling about age-related biases, something to keep in mind as you progress through your tech career. And regarding skills in an absolute sense: another point to keep in mind about tech is that skills can age very, very rapidly. Today's hot technology is tomorrow's old hat, legacy, or unneeded skill. Particularly in start-ups, the focus is on what's needed right now.
- reinhardt 15y agoPlease keep the PC rhetoric out of HN. The fact that some demographic X is under or over-represented in some field Y is not by itself evidence, let alone proof, of a conspiracy against or in favor of X.
- stonemetal 15y agoCompany X anticipates getting a contract so they staff up for it. Joe gets the job. The company doesn't get the contract they lay Joe off. Where in that scenario is Joe skilled or unskilled at doing his job? The only thing I could say is Joe was skilled at getting through the job interview filter at company X and nothing else. Say Joe works for company X, and company X goes under. Is Joe less skilled than Sue who works for Company Y? There is to much noise surrounding why companies hire, fire and the process by which they do so to claim any sort of tautology around skilled = employed. Maybe if you limited it to up or out companies.