5 ms·
> the edge of the observable universe, 45 billion light-years away If the universe is 13.x billion years old, how is the edge 45 billion light years away? Assu
by wolverine876 5y ago
> the edge of the observable universe, 45 billion light-years away
If the universe is 13.x billion years old, how is the edge 45 billion light years away? Assume we're on an edge (probably not, but ...); the radius between us and the center should be <13.x billion light years, and then the radius to the far edge would be another 13.x billion light years; that seems to total <28 billion light years max.
Looking out my window ... definitely doesn't look like 45 billion ...
- gostsamo 5y agoSpace expands faster than light. Don't forget that C is the max speed of stuff in space, not of space itself.
- wolverine876 5y agoAnd space without stuff creates gravitational waves? How? Thanks for the impromptu physics lesson, BTW.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoSpace expands uniformly across all its volume, so the parts far away from us also have stuff in it. Some stuff already moves away from us faster than light.
- gostsamo 5y agoWhen space expands, it carries matter with itself just like our dog ran away with my sandwich so many years ago.
- wolverine876 5y agoSorry to be pedantic or if I'm missing the obvious: The article says: Using gravitational waves we can sense what is 45 billion light years (bly, for purposes of this post) away. That implies that something(s) at 45 bly once did generate gravity waves. If matter can't move faster than C, and if it has only been on the move for 13.x billion years, it must be less than 28 bly distant. I am given to understand that the universe can expand faster than C; I presume that the universe must lack matter beyond 28 bly. I confess that I'm not sure what exactly is expanding. Therefore, what could be located between 28 and 45 bly distant that is generating gravity waves? One possibility: the matter moves no faster than C relative to points in the universe as it stretches, but is carried faster than that relative to other parts of the universe, like a sandwich.
- Hikikomori 5y agoIf we receive light that is 13b years old the light has travelled that distance, but the source of that light is now 45bly away from us because the universe expands.
- gostsamo 5y agoImagine it like that: you are in a train and per the rules of the railway company, nobody can run in the corridors aboard the trains. Your train passes by another train where the same no-run rule applies. If you can't run and a person in the other train cannot run, how the two of you can see each other for only a brief moment before you are carried kilometers from each other? Well, the rules do not apply to the trains both of you are occupying. So, though the two of you are relatively static, the underlying infrastructure is moving in different directions with speeds which are unfeasible for the passengers. In my previous comment, me and the sandwich were sharing the brief moment of unity that was broken apart by the runaway trajectory of the dog which made reunification impossible.
- wolverine876 5y agoThank you. I recognize the trains analogy, BTW, and perhaps frames of reference, but my knowledge of the topic is very spotty. And I've also had a sandwich snatched from my fingertips, seemingly faster than light.
- alpaca128 5y agoI'm not an expert, but as far as I understand it the universe expanding means space itself is stretching at every point. Meaning if something was 1ly away in the past, it might be farther away due to that effect. This also applies to gravitational waves and anything else inside the universe.
- contravariant 5y agoYou need something with mass to generate gravitational waves, but those waves themselves can pass through empty space without any medium, or rather the empty space itself is the medium.
- hanoz 5y agoWait, what, so atoms, neutrons, quarks etc. are all growing and moving apart at the same rate as the Universe?
- simonh 5y agoThe expansion at a local level is too slow and is overwhelmed by the local forces holding these structures together. Only at the cosmic scale, where the gravitational forces between galaxies and clusters or super-clusters of galaxies are very tenuous, the expansion takes over.
- herrkanin 5y agoThe forces that keep atoms, neutrons, quarks etc bound to each other is stronger than the force caused by space expanding. Therefore, space expanding is mostly observed when measuring distance between galaxies.
- jliptzin 5y agoExpansion of space
- simonh 5y agoWhat do you think 45 billion ly deep space would look like, to the naked eye?
- wolverine876 5y agoLike the absence, in the brain, of the grey matter that detects humor. :)
- TeMPOraL 5y agoSomething something lots of Olympic-size swimming pools.
- Sharlin 5y agoBlack.
- pixl97 5y agoYep. If space didn't expand there would be a star or galaxy at every point we looked.
- contravariant 5y agoSo not black then.
- ben_w 5y agoOnly if stars and galaxies were eternal and hadn’t first formed about 13 billion years ago.
- wolverine876 5y agoWe apparently don't know why space looks black. See Olbers' Paradox. https://starchild.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/StarChild/questions/question52.html https://starchild.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/StarChild/questions/que...
- Sharlin 5y ago
- adenozine 5y agoFor someone who knows more than me: what is space? If it's able to "move" in the sense of expanding into existence faster than light can travel, what is the composition of it? Is this what dark matter is meant to explain? For something to expand faster than C means it has to be pushed at least that quicky by some other thing or some other force, right? I have no science background at all, just a few decades of sysadmin work. Is there a book I should start with?
- Sharlin 5y agoNo need to push anything. Distances between objects (that are sufficiently far away from each other) just increase as if there’s "more space" inserted between them in some sense. There’s the concept of spacetime metric, a function that’s sort of a universal measuring stick for distances in the universe, and it is "shrinking" (as in there’s a parameter that varies as a function of time) so that a distance that used to be three measuring sticks long is now three point one.
- erikpukinskis 5y ago“A Brief History of Time” by Stephen Hawking is written for the average reader and wonderful.
- simonh 5y agoThe acceleration of the expansion of the universe is sometimes attributed to “dark energy”, but that’s a placeholder term. We don’t actually know what is doing it exactly. We can just see that it seems to be happening. The ‘faster than the speed of light’ thing is only if you measure the rate of divergence of objects at very great distances from each other, tens of billions of light years. At more local scales, such as between our neighbouring galaxies and clusters, the effect is relatively small and negligible compared to gravity.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoNo one knows what space is. We know there's a thing we call "spacetime", because space and time are closely related. And we know some things about its properties. But we know nothing at all about what it's made of, or why it has the properties it does.
- bsd44 5y agoNoob here so forgive my ignorance but I thought a light-year was a unit for measuring distance, not time.
- ben_w 5y agoIt is. Light travels one lightyear per year. Although, when you have to account for anything in relativity, the expansion of the universe included, you have to be pedantic about what you mean by both distance and time because they’re both observer-dependent, albeit in a way that keeps the speed of light itself a constant.