4 ms·
>> The output of a machine simply does not qualify for copyright protection > "Simply"? If it were that simple, surely that would mean that the output of the U
by tzs 5y ago
>> The output of a machine simply does not qualify for copyright protection
> "Simply"? If it were that simple, surely that would mean that the output of the Unix "cp" program would not qualify? What about a DVD copier?
It means that the output of "cp" does not qualify for copyright protection as a derivative work. The output is still a copy of the input and would be subject to the same copyright as that input.
Roughly, a derivative work is a new work that incorporates some copyrightable elements from a previous work. The derivative work gets its own copyright separate from the copyrights of those incorporated elements.
- adriancr 5y ago> Roughly, a derivative work is a new work that incorporates some copyrightable elements from a previous work. By this logic: - someone could go and copy functions and/or entire files from GPL code bases and use them with a different license. - someone could use copilot or similar to learn from all available GPL code. Is resulting code GPL? - someone could use copilot or similar to learn from open source code of their competitors that license doesn't allow them to use. Are the results legal?
- mthoms 5y agoThe definition of a "derivative work" as stated is correct. The copyright status of a derivative work is a separate issue: A derivative work can be considered infringing, and a derivative work can be considered non-infringing (ie. due to Fair Use).
- chalst 5y agoNot necessarily. The object code produced by a compiler might best be regarded as a different form of the source code, even though it is not a copy or a new work, according to http://digital-law-online.info/lpdi1.0/treatise26.html http://digital-law-online.info/lpdi1.0/treatise26.html